who would you rather downgrade? quick poll

[felsty]

looking at getting adams and horsley in this week.. kennedy is definitely out for Horsley so the last place goes to either Milera or Magner.

Magner Trade
Pros - can keep dpp in my midfield before the byes hit me
Cons - Isnt ready to be culled and has at least another weeks worth of money to make

Milera Trade
Pros - cant see him making too much more money for me within the next few weeks
Cons - lose dpp in midfield before the bye rounds

[Jormas]

Magner, should not be culled for 2-3 weeks, still has 60K to make you.

I would downgrade Milera to Horlsey, and if you really need the DPP, upgrade Magner to Chapman/Zaha/ROK/Goodes/Sidey/etc... in 2 weeks.

[felsty]

Kennedy already goin to Horsley which takes away my dpp in mids, just a question of which one of Magner and Milera to go to Adams.. Regardless I'm still thinking Milera is going

[felsty]

Well after a huge start by Milera now Magner is catching up! Keep voting guys

[The Bomber]

Neither this week. Given the amount of trades being used for injuries you need to make the most out of your cash cows. I would only prematurely trade out a cash cow if it is an upgrade trade to a player who is at his lowest price (eg: Pendles last week or Murphy in a couple of weeks).

I doubt Horsely or Adams or any other rookie is going to be a Barlow/Curnow and be a keeper. More rookies to come in still so hold out IMO

[quinny88]

Neither this week. Given the amount of trades being used for injuries you need to make the most out of your cash cows. I would only prematurely trade out a cash cow if it is an upgrade trade to a player who is at his lowest price (eg: Pendles last week or Murphy in a couple of weeks).

I doubt Horsely or Adams or any other rookie is going to be a Barlow/Curnow and be a keeper. More rookies to come in still so hold out IMO

I tend to agree actually. I really would love horsley and adams but im down to 16 trades already and its only round 6 so i think its time to sit back and see how things unfold for a couple of weeks

[akbal]

I am faced with something very similar. Ledger (who for some reason I was convinced was coming back) is going to go for Horsley. I lost my dpp link when I traded Fyfe to Pendles. ATM I'm leaning Magner way, but that said I am pretty keen to get Chappy in and he would easily slot into either spot. The problem is that He is likely to jump up this week anyway (BE 70 something). So the question is, who is going to jump more, Chappy, Milera, or Magner?

I am on 21 trades left going into this week.