Smithy's Crisps: Please Rate!!!

[jsmithxiv]

Ok, so here's my first go for this year... Last year was my first year and I made the mistake of not doing my research early, so I'm hoping to change that this time.

Would appreciate any feedback.

Backs:

Hargrave
Hodge
H Shaw
McPharlin
Suban
Hunt
Sheppard

Midfield:

Mitchell
Deledio
Cooney
Swift (am thinking of maybe changing with Rich depending on NAB cup form)
Palmer
D Martin

Forwards:

O'Keefe
J Brown
Franklin
Porplyzia
R Gray
Walker
Watts (not really happy with him, but want someone who'll definitely play early rounds)

Reserves:

P Davis
J Trengove
Bastinac
Kayler-Thomson
Lobbe
Cordy
Griffiths
Podsiadly

[jsmithxiv]

Just to clarify... Walker in my forward line is Taylor Walker.

[cjromano]

backs are dodgey mate

shaw is as inconsistent as they come
mcpharlin is more of a key position player
suban will not improve much on last year and same goes for hunt

fairly solid midfield, swift is apparently rippin it up

watch out for porps, as a crows fan i have heard he will struggle with injuries this year

[thefly1976]

watts will play but what will his average be.... im guessing no better than last year. he might take a few seasons being a tall key position player.

whos in the rucks

[jsmithxiv]

Cheers for the input... Will have to wait and see what happens in the NAB cup.

Completely forgot the rucks.

I have Sandilands and Ottens as my starters, Lobbe and Cordy as reserves.