Old McDonald

[c-hawk]

Thoughts on trading in old McDonald for Greene or Shiel or a waste.

Pros - McDonald seems to be scoring well and could be more consistent

Cons - Burning a trade with money still to be made

Pros - McDonald could earn a lot more or become a keeper/handy bench

[Dasherman]

Tough call I'm thinking of doing the same. I think Greene is the best option Shiel is loved by Sheedy and Greene can turn the ball over which may result in some time out of the team

[StuL]

He'll make good money but con - older guys who go to other clubs to finish their careers tend not to play too many games. His role is also a playing coach. I can see him being in and out and frustrating. I'm going Treloar instead.

[picker_man]

definantly not shiels he's got 100k left in him atleast!, with greene if you had him from the start id do it but if you traded him in after round 2 not worth another trade