McDonald v Magner v Shiel - Pick only 1

[essendon2]

Magner named on the ball, same with Shiel
McDonald named on the Interchange - potential sub?  ???

[Ricochet]

Magner is the safe option, everyone will have him on the ground
i don't think Jmac will be sub after a two week break, they would have been working him over to keep his fitness up

[kilbluff1985]

Yep Magner for sure

[SydneyRox]

Magnet - no contest

[owenbond007]

magner 2/3 tons think from a rookie we all would take that any day of the week. 

[Ziplock]

everyones going magner?

mcdonald is a substantially more proven player.

im thinking of fielding him just to spite ya'll :P

[henry]

Magner for me too. Shiel will be a good emergency.

[Chopps]

everyones going magner?

mcdonald is a substantially more proven player.

im thinking of fielding him just to spite ya'll :P

i agree with you zip but so far this year magner has shown the goods from three games v mcdonald in 1

[Ziplock]

and yet...

mcdonald has a higher average

lets note as well his 98 vs sydney was his highest score EVER against them. Since 1997 he'd never scored over 90. That's showing how much on form he was/is. 

[Ziplock]

Don't want to say I told you so

but...

suck it :P told you so lol.

[tbagrocks]

havn't picked up McD, mabey look at him this week but... I just wonder how many games he's going to be playing, however he could play enough in the first  half to make good money on him so now... do I get Treloar or old Mc?