The top 4 4

Started by Capper, February 17, 2012, 11:33:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Swallow12

DEF Goddard, Scotland Deledio Birchall
MID Ablett Swan Murphy Pendles
RUCK Cox Sandi Berger Mumford
FWD Buddy, Goodes, Fyfe, Martin

SonsOfZeus

backs-goddard,lids,shaw,adcock- first 3 are self explanatory adcock if he plays in mids if not scotland/fisher
mids-ablett,selwood,swan,boyd- ablett is the best player in the comp, selwood is a gun, swan will rack again and boyd is the most underrated player in the comp and is a good unique
rucks-sandi,mumford,cox,mcevoy- first 3 on reputation, mcevoy just over luey because saints have an easier draw and will be a force this season
fwds-franklin,pav,chapman,goodes- franklin is the most influential player in the fwds, pav is fitter than ever as is chappy and chappy said he let his team down last year and is over injuries, with reid and tommy walsh goodes should play more onball than forward.

stevie j is overatted IMO and loves the weaker sides. left out pendles and NDS just(reckon montagna will go close)

Capper

Quote from: SonsOfZeus on February 19, 2012, 12:30:23 AM
backs-goddard,lids,shaw,adcock- first 3 are self explanatory adcock if he plays in mids if not scotland/fisher
mids-ablett,selwood,swan,boyd- ablett is the best player in the comp, selwood is a gun, swan will rack again and boyd is the most underrated player in the comp and is a good unique
rucks-sandi,mumford,cox,mcevoy- first 3 on reputation, mcevoy just over luey because saints have an easier draw and will be a force this season
fwds-franklin,pav,chapman,goodes- franklin is the most influential player in the fwds, pav is fitter than ever as is chappy and chappy said he let his team down last year and is over injuries, with reid and tommy walsh goodes should play more onball than forward.

stevie j is overatted IMO and loves the weaker sides. left out pendles and NDS just(reckon montagna will go close)

Isnt adcock carrying an injury??  Pav is also an interesting choice, will he just play upfront

Jay


ando_10

backs- Goddard Shaw Deledio Birchall (scotland maybe just missing out)

mids- Swan Ablett Pendles Dal Santo

Rucks- Cox Sandi Mumford Mcevoy

Forwards- Fyfe Johnson Buddy Goodes

in no order by the way.

4INAROW

goddard, shaw, deledio, birchall/ broughton-if used in mid role more.

gaj, pendles, swan, boyd

cox, mummy, sandi, leuey

buddy, goodes, fyfe, chappy

Capper

Quote from: tabs on February 17, 2012, 11:37:57 PM
BAC - Gods, Lids, Heater, Birchall
MIDS - Ablet, Swan, Pendles, Jelwood
RUC - Cox, Sandi, Mummy, Berger
FWDS - Buddy, Goodes, Stevie J, Ricky Martin
ok guys, 4 weeks in lets see what your top 4 4 are now

BAC - Gods, Lids, Heater, Birchall, Scotland
MIDS - Ablet, Swan, Pendles, Jelwood, Mitchell, Murphy
RUC - Cox, Sandi, Mummy, Berger HMAC
FWDS - Buddy, Goodes, Stevie J, Ricky Martin, Chappy, Nroo

MC

Quote from: tabs on April 23, 2012, 02:41:02 AM
Quote from: tabs on February 17, 2012, 11:37:57 PM
BAC - Gods, Lids, Heater, Birchall
MIDS - Ablet, Swan, Pendles, Jelwood
RUC - Cox, Sandi, Mummy, Berger
FWDS - Buddy, Goodes, Stevie J, Ricky Martin
ok guys, 4 weeks in lets see what your top 4 4 are now

BAC - Gods, Lids, Heater, Birchall, Scotland
MIDS - Ablet, Swan, Pendles, Jelwood, Mitchell, Murphy
RUC - Cox, Sandi, Mummy, Berger HMAC
FWDS - Buddy, Goodes, Stevie J, Ricky Martin, Chappy, Nroo

Selwood averaging 130+ not good enough for top4? Wow.

Capper

Quote from: MC on April 23, 2012, 01:49:05 PM
Quote from: tabs on April 23, 2012, 02:41:02 AM
Quote from: tabs on February 17, 2012, 11:37:57 PM
BAC - Gods, Lids, Heater, Birchall
MIDS - Ablet, Swan, Pendles, Jelwood
RUC - Cox, Sandi, Mummy, Berger
FWDS - Buddy, Goodes, Stevie J, Ricky Martin
ok guys, 4 weeks in lets see what your top 4 4 are now

BAC - Gods, Lids, Heater, Birchall, Scotland
MIDS - Ablet, Swan, Pendles, Jelwood, Mitchell, Murphy
RUC - Cox, Sandi, Mummy, Berger HMAC
FWDS - Buddy, Goodes, Stevie J, Ricky Martin, Chappy, Nroo

Selwood averaging 130+ not good enough for top4? Wow.
yeh but i think he replaces ablet now as he is out for 2-3

MC

Quote from: MC on February 17, 2012, 11:41:09 PM
Backs: God/Lids/Shaw/Birchall Suckling  --> Can see Scotland dropping off a touch, Birchall should step up!
Mids: Pendles/NDS/GAJ/Murphy Selwood --> Clear-cut premiums can only be stopped by unforeseen injuries.
Rucks: Mummy/Cox/Sandilands/Luenberger Nic Nat  --> Goldstein to drop off with Hmac stepping up a bit.
Fwd: Buddy/Goodes/Martin/Fyfe Nroo, T Cloke, Tippett (Maybe) --> Martin will explode this year, and I can't see Pav/Chappy/StevieJ getting into the top4.


*Selections in no particular order.


Obviously made a few errors here, but so did everyone else!