Let me have it.

Started by footsteps, January 09, 2010, 05:38:03 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

footsteps

Michael Doughty     
Sam Fisher     
Luke Hodge         
Heath Shaw       
Andrew Walker       
Rick Ladson       
Tadhg Kennelly         

Jimmy Bartel       
Scott Pendlebury       
Adam Cooney         
Rhys Palmer       
Dustin Martin         
Anthony Morabito       

Aaron Sandilands         
Matthew Kreuzer       

Matthew Pavlich       
Shaun Higgins         
Lance Franklin       
Cyril Rioli       
Patrick Dangerfield       
Jack Trengove         
Ben Cunnington       

Matt Maguire         
Phil Davis       
Lewis Jetta         
Mitch Banner       
Daniel Currie       
Matthew Lobbe       
Trent Dennis-Lane       
Luke Tapscott

Plus 120K, so rookies can easily change, not sure about the forward line.

Don't mind starting 4 rookies, i can count 14 keepers, and with the 120K should be able to upgrade another pretty easy.

Clint-84

Doughty is getting old and will probably do alot of tagging this year so maybe go for someone like Embley, Adcock or Carrazzo instead.
Walker probably won't play in the early rounds, someone like Stephen Hill or Scott Selwood would be a better option with more upside as they will play more of a midfield role this year.

Starting 2 rookies in the mids could be a little risky but those 2 guys should get plenty of games this year.

Rucks are solid.

Forwards aren't too bad but Buddy may be underdone and will miss round 1 due to suspension.

I would probably downgrade Walker to Sheppard form WCE and use that cash along with the 120k to upgrade either  Morabito or Martin to a premium type player around the 400k mark.

Blueboys

Ok hahahaha

Backs: Looks good

Walker might miss

Mids:

No Gaza  >:(
Too many rookies playing could cost you.

Rucks: Strong

Forwards:

Too many rookies playing
Injuries with higgins & Riolio

Over all:

Backs look strong, but not sure with all the rookies you have playing in the mids and forwards. That could cost you.

jimmytigs

Andrew Walker       

Matthew Kreuzer       

Mitch Banner       
Daniel Currie       
Matthew Lobbe       
Trent Dennis-Lane   

Quite like your team,will be keenly following the fortunes of walker myself,he is a great fit in every way as long as he hasnt put him self out.Would look at cheaper options than Kruezer & that would allow you to get at least a better 3rd ruck option also.ot familiar with Banner or Lane are they likely to get on field?   



Clint-84

I don't agree with Jimmytigs about Kreuzer.

You don't need to spend cash on a 3rd ruck, you just need him to be able to come in and get some points on the board if one of your rucks goes down for a week or 2. If it's a long term injury then you would trade him out anyway.
A couple of rookie priced rucks who should play alot of games are Lobbe and Trengove from Port.
Leave ur rucks as is, good combo IMO.