Coniglio or Shiel OUT for Greene?

[thatguy]

yes Greene's disposal is pretty woeful, but hey, how many of the Giants can you say arent in that boat?

Shiel and Coniglio? ;)

Fair enough, agree to disagree mate. Hard to get a read on a lot of these players after just two rounds, but that's the name of the game for us unfortunately. I'd be curious to know which of Greene/Coniglio/Shiel you have in your team, and when you got them?

started with shiel and coniglio (and old farmer mcdonald too)
will more than likely be trading coniglio to greene this week, for 2 reasons. 1st is i believe greene will be the curnow/libba of last yr, only needs to play another 5 games and he has done his job, and secondly with the spare $40k i can upgrade broughton to birchall.

[Justin Bieber]

Mind due, the whole GWS team butcher the ball cause of pressure. So it's not oly Greene.

[Doyle]

There should be a 'neither' option, just trade someone else e.g. McDonald.

[ENYGMA]

cant help you with that one matt1985 i have caddy coniglio shiel ledger and magner. 3 of them i need to start, ledger will play a full game and score a ton like i expected him to do when i picked him - OR he will be traded to macdonald.

can even caddy at $250K outscore greene can cogs can shiel? i would say the first 2 could easily but will they?

my only concern with greene is he gets a lot of touches but that doesnt mean he is playing well and there will be a lot of changes this week, i think if he survives the cut this week (adams, treloar and others due a game) he might be worth the trade, but even if he stays and someone like treloar and adams comes into the midfield will greene still score as well, will he be sub any tyson given a full game?

Go with your gut :) but in support of your argument even if greene doesnt score as well he at least will be the one that makes the most coin...

What if Shiel or Coniglio aren't named this week but Greene is?  :o

[Plastic Boy]

Burning a trade for $40k.... it could easily turn around and Greene scores ordinary and Congilio tears it up... I'm not getting sucked in

[Windigo]

There should be a 'neither' option, just trade someone else e.g. Dickson if you have him for McDonald.

Not many people have that option......Obviously they want to trade.  :P

[Ricochet]

Mind due, the whole GWS team butcher the ball cause of pressure. So it's not oly Greene.

and wasn't it blowing a gale. not ideal for skills

[TheHanger]

Mind due, the whole GWS team butcher the ball cause of pressure. So it's not oly Greene.

mate the expression is mind you, not mind due

[Justin Bieber]

Mind due, the whole GWS team butcher the ball cause of pressure. So it's not oly Greene.

mate the expression is mind you, not mind due

Yes I know.

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

coniglio OUT greene IN

I'm on the uncertainty express :D

[matt1985]

I have seen a few posts about maybe Dom Tyson could sneak into Greenes spot and make Greene a target to be subbed. But after seeing Tyson out with injury, it boosts my confidence in picking Greene.

[BillyPil]

I probably should have had a neither option on the poll, but there ya go. I ended up going Kerridge for Greene and I'm starting him on the field ahead of Conigs and Shiel.

Will definitely have to get rid of one or two of them before the bye, and hopefully that should coincide with Neale being on the bubble.  Fingers crossed!  Thanks for all the advice fellas, some really helpful discussion here.

:D