Which forwards in and out?

[Carlton123]

Wondering who to trade out between Tory Dickson (WB) and Aaron Hall (GC), leaning towards Dickson due to his low score in Round 1 and starting as a sub in Round 2. Also not sure who to trade in out of Milera and Kennedy. My other trade this week will be Shiel - Greene. Any advice would be great thanks.

[lolrocket]

Of those, Dickson -> Kennedy

but Greene's JS is a bit sketchy apparently so perhaps Shiel -> Kennedy and Dickson -> Milera is an option as well?

Surely you have a mid rook that needs trading more than Shiel as well and there are two options for Dickson -> Kennedy in the poll

[esquire]

Just remember Dickson scored low with less TOG than Hall who has just scored low. Gaff started the first few rounds as sub for WCE and just had to build up to a full game. However that said, neither Hall nor Dickson are particularly setting the world on fire atm. However, it's a sideways trade - rookie for a rookie. I wouldn't IMO.

[FlipFlops]

Personally i've gone Dickson to Kennedy this week. Looking at how Dickson is been used compared with Kennedy, Kennedy is likely to make you alot more $$$ and make it easier for you to turn him into a premium further down the track. And it's only 1 trade  ;) JUST DO IT!

On your other trade idea i wouldn't be trading out Shiel at this stage, i think he can average around the same as Greene, it'll just take him longer to fatten up. If your willing to burn 2 trades early on though then go for it but i wouldn't be doing it myself.

[disastrous]

Smedts has hurt is shoulder (think it was) and is out indefinitely, so probably better to get rid of him  ;D

I agree, if you don't yet have Kennedy, do it, he's going to bump at least 70-80k this week

[Windigo]

I wouldn't read much into the Smedts injury.

Didn't even get subbed? Or did he?  ???

[picker_man]

I wouldn't read much into the Smedts injury.

Didn't even get subbed? Or did he?  ???

yeah prietty sure he did late in the 3rd quarter

[Justin Bieber]

No change, but long list. With big O in.

[Zombie2.5]

I actually have no idea, but i reckon the smedts thing was a precaution.
Hes still named although hes on 7man bench it probably means he isnt injured.

Dickson to Kennedy EASY, low scores from dickson and hes been dropped(knew it!) plus kennedy is still named at HB and that can only look good(round 1 again anyone?).

[Windigo]

Yep, Dicko>Kennedy is a good trade.