keeping broughton......... but A. Hall????

[sledgey7]

gonna stick with the heartbreaker and hope he comes good.
everybody worried about him not moving to the midfield but remember he's scored plenty of tons running out of defense and laying large amounts of tackles.

The only other trade on my mind is Hall but i actually think he's shown signs and a couple of games getting used to the pace will be very beneficial. anyways with smith and kennedy already in my forwards, milera is the only logical replacement and i really can't see that as being a sensible sideways trade.

still everybody gets an itchy trigger finger after rnd 2 don't they.

[PowerBug]

Why trade Hall?? You shouldn't unless you are forced to play him each week. And even then.....

[fertalong]

I'm in a similar dilemma but I have Tory Dickson sitting on my fwd with A.Kennedy in mid. I am also thinking about going Dickson to Greene if dickson is named on bench/sub again this week.

If you have Kennedy and Smith in fwd, you probably wont need milera, and it's just a wasted trade since hall should avg 60ish

[sledgey7]

i told you why.
because it's bubble time and i have an itch that needs a scratch.

haha

nah. i'm inside the top 1000 and have johnno brown to come off the pine this week so i can't really complain.

[Football Factory]

Do you have a Thoopercoach team .. i always scratch an itch on there .. last year in the first 8 weeks i made 16 trades  8)   ;D

[Windigo]

I'd keep Azza. Silly trades now will jeopardize you down the track.

[Andrew]

I'm definately ditching one of Hall & Dickson to Milera, as I have to play one of them... surely worthwhile to get a far greater price increase in Milera anyway? If one of them is dropped then that'll make the decision easier. But I am thinking of holding off the trade and getting in Jono Brown in a couple of weeks anyway.

[The F.A.R.K.]

so everyone is jumping on milera when he has had port adelaide and gold coast in his first two games....he hasnt been a terrific player just lucky his team have had easy games (dt wise) he might only score one more decent score and then goodbye

[Windigo]

so everyone is jumping on milera when he has had port adelaide and gold coast in his first two games....he hasnt been a terrific player just lucky his team have had easy games (dt wise) he might only score one more decent score and then goodbye

Yeah, pretty much.  :P

[upthemaidens]

problem with keeping broughton is if next week he gets 68,(drops 50k) week after he gets 74(drops 35k)week later he gets 63(drops38k) etc.  at what point do you bite the bullet?  your overall chances will be shot by the then, he will have about as much value as a PS2 console... on the flip side he starts scoring well as soon as you trade him out...
    damned if u do,damned if u dont :)

[Windigo]

Double edged sword, but in a game where Pav stunk it as well....

[upthemaidens]

i think if you dont care about overall, and only going for league then just keep him...otherwise..

[sledgey7]

clearly the broughton issue comes down to your gut and only having yourself to blame if you are wrong.
my gut says keep. he'll come good.
if he doesn't score at least a 90+ in the next 2 games though, i will drop him.

[sledgey7]

Do you have a Thoopercoach team .. i always scratch an itch on there .. last year in the first 8 weeks i made 16 trades  8)   ;D

NEVER!!
staunch dter

[picker_man]

broughton will be droppped out more then 50% of teams i reckon and its just the way the world works that he will then go on his run of  decent scores and make them all look like fools! (so keep him)
just before the run happens im going to get him in for less then an item on the loose change menu :P