SC attempt 2010, thoughts?

Started by Wookie, December 16, 2009, 07:46:21 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Wookie

Drummond
Lake
Hodge
Birchall
Rance
Malceski
B. Sheppard

davis
maguire

Hayes
Murphy
Burgoyne
Rioli
Hill
Scully

Morabito
Farmer

Tippet
Kreuzer

Skipper
Warnock

Goodes
Higgins
Franklin
Le Cras
Ed Barlow
Dangerfield
T Walker


Tapscott
Bastinac

$38k in the kitty

So anything anyone thinks is a bad move??

Hawks_1976

I don't like Malceski. Swans have plenty of rebounding ability in Kennelly, Mattner and Shaw. Maybe Kennelly instead.
You need Ablett in SC as captain. No one has averaged close to him in the last two seasons and he is in his prime. Maybe Ablett instead of Hayes and bring Morabito onto the field for Hill.
Goodes is overpriced as a start up foward but will be a valuable upgrade target during the season when his price drops. Riewoldt is far more reliable here.
Walker will struggle to get a game in a foward line that boasts Tippett, Hentschel, Burton, Porplyzia and Knights. Consider Mayne, Yarran or Veszpremi here.

Kangamagic

Wookie,

I agree get rid of Malceski - replace him with Kennelly or Hunt. I had Malceski this season after he came back from his injury he was terrible.

I would get GAJ into your team he is a gun! I like Murphy, Burgoyne (has to get fit over pre-season with his knee), Rioli and Scully and Morabito should start on the paddock.

Rucks are solid maybe downgrade one of Skipper or Warnock for a (94K player) free up some cash.

I dont like Barlow or Walker. Maybe get some rookies to start for you like Johnstone(Sydney) Lucas (Carlton), Gumbleton (Essendon).

Magic

vendy_9

malcheski was the worst player i had last season