moving on broughton and gibbs

Started by BBosCo, April 09, 2012, 10:56:13 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

which option?

birchall and watson
4 (21.1%)
waters and pendlebury
13 (68.4%)
fisher and stanton
2 (10.5%)

Total Members Voted: 0

BBosCo

i know its early to be trading gibbs but i just dont like how up and down his scoring can be. plus he is frustrating to watch, never gets his own ball.

Sledgendary

I'm with you - a lot of people saying back in the research done pre-season and keep these guys. For me there was a risk in picking Broughton with the hope that a new coach would see increase midfield time. It doesn't look like that's panning out - also their midfield squad looks like it may run deeper then last year with more guns due back in - too risky that he'll stay a dud.
Gibbs is an out and out gun, however I was hoping for a move to a more permanent midfield role. Hasn't happened. I am hesitant on this one as Carlton has a few key defenders due back which may free him up? Tough call.
Options - Broughton to Clarke or Hargraeve ( I voted on Waters for your situation )
Gibbs - Pendlebury, Stanton ( similar thinking to you ) or even Sloane setting me up with a large bankroll for upgrades later. Still don't think I'm sold on Sloane, my midfield just looks better with Pendlebury sitting there...

ThePendles

#2
Go with Waters and Pendles. Waters is great value at that price and will definitely increase in price, they got GWS this week aswell. I don't even need to explain why you need Pendlebury, dude is an absolute gun and almost a must for every team.