Mad Max's Supercoach Diary

[Madmax75]

Great idea whoever started this diary thing. My latest draft:

B Goddard Deledio Broughton H Shaw Lake Ellis Bug  Brown Townsend
C  Ablett Selwood Swallow  Hayes  Kerridge Allen McDonald
R Leuenberger McEvoy Stephenson Giles
F Buddy Pav  Martin Porps Treloar Smedts Hall Couch

I have put Lenny back in because last year I had backups at B C and forward with all the resting of players so either he's a m6 or m7 by the end. Also Pendles upgrade after bye and swan after Arizona. Thoughts ?

[Madmax75]

Also had the Cox Mummy ruck combo in at last draft but at the cost of H Shaw out and rookie back in?  Thoughts on this ?

[spasticnut]

good team but i would just try and get at least 2 more premiums in your team to start with. Overall 8.8/10

[Madmax75]

Actually Goodes should be in their as F2 typo

[Madmax75]

Updated team:

Thanks mate actually Goodes should be in their as F2

B Goddard Deledio Broughton H Shaw Lake Ellis Bug  Brown Townsend
C  Ablett Selwood Swallow  Hayes  Kerridge Allen McDonald
R Leuenberger McEvoy Stephenson Giles
F Buddy Pav Goodes Martin Porps Treloar Smedts Hall Couch

[nicw98]

First of all great team. Maybe change Pav to Fyfe. A bit of a risk not have Swan Pendles or Boyd. Maybe downgrade L'Berger or McEvoy to Hmac. Then with the cash upgrade Swallow or Hayes. 8.3/10.

[Ringo]

Can i suggest if running as a diary that you keep modifying the first post with updated team and just let the comments come.  It will allow very interesting comparisons.
eg look at my team thread. http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,44626.0.html
Regards your Team
Backs Solid - Assume it a typo with Shaw at D4 prefer Broughton at D4 rather than D3.
Mids: Solid - The usual question mark over Hayes but may pay of,
Rucks - Set and forget - Maybe look at Reddan rather than Stephenson based on NAB cup form.
Forwards: Solid.
Not sure how much cash you have left but I would definitely look at getting Swan or Pendles into mids as soon as possible.

Not a bad team 8/10

[Madmax75]

Yep no worries thanks Ringo will check yours out. Yep typo Shaw D3 Brougton D4. To get Pendles in would have to downgrade Shaw and upgrade Hayes. Just a problem with Redden instead of Stephenson with the byes as I would then have a ruck 0.
Updated Team:


B Goddard Deledio Broughton Adcock Ellis Allen Bug  Brown Townsend
C Pendlles Ablett Selwood Swallow Magner Cunningham McDonald Gibson
R Leuenberger McEvoy Stephenson Giles
F Buddy Goodes Pavlich Martin Porps Treloar Kerridge Couch Hall

Major changes being:
Out H Shaw Lake Hayes
In Adcock Cunningham Pendles
Any thoughts please

[Madmax75]

I have had another look at my team and made the following changes.

Major changes being:
Out Townsend Pendles Leunberger Pavlich Goodes Hall
In Lake Thompson Mumford Fyfe Sidebottom Dickson
Any thoughts please


B Goddard Deledio Broughton Adcock Lake Ellis Allen Bug  Brown 
C  Ablett Selwood Swallow Thompson Magner Cunningham McDonald Gibson
R Mumford McEvoy Stephenson Giles
F Buddy Fyfe Martin Sidebottom Porps Treloar Kerridge Couch Dickson

[Madmax75]

Thinking of whether I'll make some correctional trades to bring in Kennedy from gws and c smith from dogs next week. My team is :

B Goddard Deledio Broughton Grimes Lake Morris Bug  Smedts Ellis
C Ablett Selwood Thompson Watson McDonald Shiels Magner Cunningham
R Mumford Cox Stephenson Giles
F Buddy Fyfe Martin Danger Porps Paine T Dickson A Hall Couch

So with 26k in the bank Cunningham T Dickson out and Kennedy C Smith in ?

[Madmax75]

Any thoughts anyone ?

[Ringo]

Do not mind the trades in - Definitely Cunningham out for Smith but I would wait to see how Dickson and Paine go to see who to trade for Kennedy.  Not sure whether Paines DPP with Smedts is worth it.

[Madmax75]

Yep paine needs to be looked at too. Would like to get a dpp mid in the mids to set that up

[Ringo]

Adam Kennedy has a mid/forward DPP so you are covered there. If you wish to have Back/Mid DPP not a lot of options out there but keep an eye out for Docherty to return as a suitable downgrade target when some of your rooks may max out.  Do not think need both DPP links this year but just a personal opinion.

[Madmax75]

I don't think I'll burn a trade on C Smith with yesterday's score but depending on Kennedy's score Cunningham out for him.