Kennedy vs Smith

[Spite]

Do you think Kennedy's 116 was a one off? I think I will be starting D. Smith, but not too sure. I know he can rack it up on occasion, it may be a good POD over kennedy.

[elephants]

I only have Dev Smith. I would honestly go him despite the fact I am bringing in Kennedy this week.

[underdog11]

Not entirely sure. He won't be post those sort of numbers regularly, but will be a solid scorer. Smith got 69 and played ff, and is set to push up the ground more, will dominate! i have both, but I would play Smith, if i were choosing one.

[MGK1]

Good thread. Kennedy posted quite similar scores for his game time in the nab cup.

Hes a year older than all of the other rookies and is an absolute ball magnet who plays in the backline.

Smith is quality but won't see as much of the ball as Kennedy due to playing closer to the forward line.

Kennedy > Smith for this week. Both however is an option if you have Hall/Dickson etc.

[thatguy]

Good thread. Kennedy posted quite similar scores for his game time in the nab cup.

Hes a year older than all of the other rookies and is an absolute ball magnet who plays in the backline.

Smith is quality but won't see as much of the ball as Kennedy due to playing closer to the forward line.

Kennedy > Smith for this week. Both however is an option if you have Hall/Dickson etc.

couldnt agree more

[Colliwobblers]

I have kennedy- smith - dickson. I also have Tom T Lynch, I will role the dice on Lynch one more round in the hope he doesn't start sub- he scored 38 from 30% TOG so will score well enough if played and not a sub.

Which leaves one of the 3 rooks to start which I will have to go kennedy on form.

BUT

Scully and Taylor Adams will be automatic inclusions this week along with Treloar if he is fit which I think he is...

I think Hampton, Kennedy and Smith all played well enough to hold thier spots but they can't all hold thier spots.

Very risky round ahead with the GWS rooks. Kennedy for me.

I made need to replace Ledger in the middle and as much as I love the look of Tayulor Adams and Greene and Tyson for that matter I don't have clay smith and the JS of GWS rooks no matter how good is not solid enough to pick one over any other good rook from any other club that will have JS.

Watch for ZORKO to be named, he will go well and hold his spot at the Lions if he does. Already in my SC team and already scored me 104 SC points (kennedy's)  ;D

[Ricochet]

I have kennedy- smith - dickson. I also have Tom T Lynch, I will role the dice on Lynch one more round in the hope he doesn't start sub- he scored 38 from 30% TOG so will score well enough if played and not a sub.

Which leaves one of the 3 rooks to start which I will have to go kennedy on form.

BUT

Scully and Taylor Adams will be automatic inclusions this week along with Treloar if he is fit which I think he is...

I think Hampton, Kennedy and Smith all played well enough to hold thier spots but they can't all hold thier spots.

Very risky round ahead with the GWS rooks. Kennedy for me.

I made need to replace Ledger in the middle and as much as I love the look of Tayulor Adams and Greene and Tyson for that matter I don't have clay smith and the JS of GWS rooks no matter how good is not solid enough to pick one over any other good rook from any other club that will have JS.

Watch for ZORKO to be named, he will go well and hold his spot at the Lions if he does. Already in my SC team and already scored me 104 SC points (kennedy's)  ;D

With Power, Brogan and Scully can they fit these two in? Faark GWS are going to have to drop a few

[Justin Bieber]

I'm playing both over hall and couch (hehe)

[Windigo]

I only have Dev Smith. I would honestly go him despite the fact I am bringing in Kennedy this week.

Trading already?  :o

I'm playing both.

[Colliwobblers]

we were warned that is all i can say, the best rooks except a few are all GWS but they will be in and out of the side every other game, most people will have a bunch so don't stress as long as there are enough rooks to field you'll be in a similar situation to everyone else but yeah 2-6 rooks that played last week very well may not play this week for GWS.

[elephants]

I only have Dev Smith. I would honestly go him despite the fact I am bringing in Kennedy this week.

Trading already?  :o

I'm playing both.

False alarm, meant next week :)

[Windigo]

I only have Dev Smith. I would honestly go him despite the fact I am bringing in Kennedy this week.

Trading already?  :o

I'm playing both.

False alarm, meant next week :)

Ah good. But still, surely you would have considered getting Kennedy before lockout?  ???

[elephants]

I only have Dev Smith. I would honestly go him despite the fact I am bringing in Kennedy this week.

Trading already?  :o

I'm playing both.

False alarm, meant next week :)

Ah good. But still, surely you would have considered getting Kennedy before lockout?  ???

Don't start me again...

[Football Factory]

I have both .. started both .. and will start both this week aslong as they are named