the old 'Who to Field?'

Started by Bill Manspeaker, April 05, 2012, 01:46:21 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

pick 2 backs, 2 mids, 1 ruck and 2 fwds

back - M.Clarke
22 (2200%)
back - Bugg
25 (2500%)
back - Ellis
5 (500%)
back - Morris
2 (200%)
mids - Magner
26 (2600%)
mids - Shiel
18 (1800%)
mids - Ledger
8 (800%)
ruck - Giles
25 (2500%)
ruck - Redden
3 (300%)
fwds - Kennedy
25 (2500%)
fwds - D.Smith
20 (2000%)
fwds - Cameron
0 (0%)
fwds - Couch
6 (600%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Bill Manspeaker

okay so i've pretty much locked Bugg, Magner and Kennedy in..

pending on who's playing of course.. (Couch, Ellis?, Ledger)
if i had a million bucks, i'd bet it all on Ledger getting a game this week, he'll actually win us a hard ball or 2. It's probably because i'm a little biased, but i really wanna field him.. but would really love to see some thoughts!

cheers

Mr.Craig

Quote from: brad on April 05, 2012, 01:46:21 AM
okay so i've pretty much locked Bugg, Magner and Kennedy in..

pending on who's playing of course.. (Couch, Ellis?, Ledger)
if i had a million bucks, i'd bet it all on Ledger getting a game this week, he'll actually win us a hard ball or 2. It's probably because i'm a little biased, but i really wanna field him.. but would really love to see some thoughts!

cheers

Well you never know, it might end up being a better move to have Ledger on the field. Magnet could be a late withdrawl.

Mr.Craig

Quote from: Mr.Craig on April 05, 2012, 01:55:26 AM
Quote from: brad on April 05, 2012, 01:46:21 AM
okay so i've pretty much locked Bugg, Magner and Kennedy in..

pending on who's playing of course.. (Couch, Ellis?, Ledger)
if i had a million bucks, i'd bet it all on Ledger getting a game this week, he'll actually win us a hard ball or 2. It's probably because i'm a little biased, but i really wanna field him.. but would really love to see some thoughts!

cheers

Well you never know, it might end up being a better move to have Ledger on the field. Magnet could be a late withdrawl.

But I guess if you have Magnet on the field and Ledger as emg you'd get his score anyway. Whatever... :P

kilbluff1985

These are pretty much no brainers as the poll shows

Bill Manspeaker

Quote from: kilbluff1995 on April 05, 2012, 02:00:10 AM
These are pretty much no brainers as the poll shows

yeah i thought that aswell, i was gonna just do a a 2 out of Ledger, Magner and Shiel but i thought i'd go all out and put everyone on there :P

Quote from: Mr.Craig on April 05, 2012, 01:58:32 AM
Quote from: Mr.Craig on April 05, 2012, 01:55:26 AM
Quote from: brad on April 05, 2012, 01:46:21 AM
okay so i've pretty much locked Bugg, Magner and Kennedy in..

pending on who's playing of course.. (Couch, Ellis?, Ledger)
if i had a million bucks, i'd bet it all on Ledger getting a game this week, he'll actually win us a hard ball or 2. It's probably because i'm a little biased, but i really wanna field him.. but would really love to see some thoughts!

cheers

Well you never know, it might end up being a better move to have Ledger on the field. Magnet could be a late withdrawl.

But I guess if you have Magnet on the field and Ledger as emg you'd get his score anyway. Whatever... :P

lol thanks for ya thoughts mate, i'm hoping there's some love out there for Ledger to convince me a little more to field him..

Holz

wait till you at least see the team sheets.

owenbond007

prettty obvious what you hope to achieve here. 7 rookies on field is a touch ballsy in my own opinion. Giles over redden. Smith kennedy up front. Buggs Ellis forwards. Magner + 1 in mids.