Who are you considering in SC from Essendon next year?

Started by Hawks_1976, November 25, 2009, 01:31:21 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Hawks_1976

I'm considering:

David Myers
Mark McVeigh
Brent Prismall
Kyle Reimers?
David Hille
Scott Gumbleton ( bench )

vitch

G/day Hawks - I reckon you're on the money with Prismall, had an amazing 2nd half of the year after no pre season, watch out next season - expensive but elite. I like Myers as well & Gumby if he ever plays. Watch out for Zararakis, Dempsey and my "smokie" Bachar Houli.

Hawks_1976

At the moment I'm trying to structure Prismall in as my 4th or 5th mid. At a similar price, Cooney should score in a similar fashion I think.

vitch

there's a heap of proven performers around that price just under the top priced mids - cross, judd, black, power, pendlebury, thompson, deledio etc etc none of them are gunna let you down but I reckon prismal is untapped - probably a bit biased though. I reckon cotchin is worth looking at for a cheaer mid with scope.

HillHero13

Prismall will be free'd up around th ground knowing that watson will probably get the tag

Alex7089

Yeah except watson is a hard player to tag because he goes and wins his own bal and it's hard to stop him doing that

Crushemall

I thought Bachar Houli was a great value defender and i definitely think Gumby on the forward bench but Hille is the Big ? he has that injury prone X factor big risk and I thought Mark williams is a watcher

brodman_18

Gumby on bench, big risk but also big rewards. If Hille plays good in the NAB challenge, i might get him. Couldn't squeeze in hocking or Meyers

Justin Bieber

i've got hooker. needed one essendon defender and liked him better than pears.

would of considered winderlich if he plays on the wing but looks like he will play mainly forward pocket. maybe stanton instead?
williams and bachar ones to watch. bashar to see if he will play games and williams to see if he can handle the best defender like the old days.