Possible Trade

[swanny89]

Mulling over whether or not to pull one of these trades inthe next 2 weeks. They're kind of sideways, so not sure if there is enough value in them to make them worthwile - am just keen to work smith into my lineup.

Coniglio OR Lucas (if he is going to be continually vested) --> Smith
Ellis OR Morris --> Hargrave

What do you guys think? Worth the trades?

[LF]

No its not worth trading next week wait another week at least and see.

[Colliwobblers]

yeah don't trade rooks until at least after round 2, only LTI or EPIC FAILED Premiums are worth trading at this point.

[Nails]

Considered pre lockout having 4th ruck a throw away and started Giles/Redden w/ Orren as 3rd...

Tempted to go HMac > Derickx (or similar) and then I could do some big upgrade...

But I'm going to wait to AT LEAST  after rd2, trades this early as a general rule are a mistake.

[swanny89]

Yeah, I did mean after round 2. Just trying to get some opinions on it. Mainly on whether people think Lucas will cop the vest all season/Hargrave will play most of the season as a rebounding defender.

[billnats]

I was thinking the same thing.
McIntosh --> Redden and that will give me cash to get in C. Smith and upgrade Sidebottom-->Franklin.

Mumford and Giles on field and Redden/Stephenson on bench. Noticed that Redden got subbed today. Too much of a risk?

Alternatively, I can trade Coniglio-->S. Smith and upgrade McIntosh--> Kreuzer.

What you reckon?

[StuL]

How many trades is it worth burning to repair f**k ups? I say about 2. I wouldn't get too excited about under-performing kids in the forwards and backs; don't think ANY set the world on fire. You want to gun rookie mids though and I have Magner and Smith so happy with them.

[swanny89]

How many trades is it worth burning to repair f**k ups? I say about 2. I wouldn't get too excited about under-performing kids in the forwards and backs; don't think ANY set the world on fire. You want to gun rookie mids though and I have Magner and Smith so happy with them.

Yeah, Coniglio isn't exactly a spud though... Worth burning a trade to move him out for Smith?

[PowerBug]

Blease to Smith sound right??


OR is there a better fwd rookie i should look at getting?? I'll trade out Blease, move one of D.Smith or Couch to the mids and trade in a Fwd rookie??

Thoughts on either of those options.

[Lucastorm]

Hey,

Loving the banter on the forums.

Problem - so many acronyms and nicknames it's hard to keep up with what the f&&k people are talking about....

Colliwobblers - what does LTI stand for?

The rest - who is HMac (i knew at one point, but have forgotten) and S.Smith?

Cheers fellas and happy hunting

[PowerBug]

LTI = long term injury

HMac = Hamish McIntosh (Yes Brat Pack, i said his name :P)

Not suyre about S.SMith, think you mean C.Smith which is Doggies rookie Clay Smith.

[Windigo]

Don't trade mate. You'll be thankful later on in the season.

[Lucastorm]

Cheers, I was thinking Clay too, thats why that freakin S got me confused.

Cheers!

[JBs-Hawks]

Trade trade trade :) just give me the keys to the car now :)

[Jukes]

or EPIC FAILED Premiums are worth trading at this point.

Cough cough shaw cough cough