Adcock or Broughton?

[sammy]

my current backs are Goddard, Deledio, Carrazzo, Adcock/Broughton, Hargrave, Clarke, Bugg (Ellis, Townsend)

I was going to go with Suckling but i don't have the money anymore so it's gotta be either Adcock or Broughton.

[fertalong]

Broughton without a 2nd thought.

[picker_man]

if you've ever considered hanley can you add him to the poll so i dont have to start another thread ;)

[Windigo]

I'd go Broughton.

[FlipFlops]

Just read http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/131872/default.aspx and traded out Heath Shaw for Broughton. Also downgraded Thompson to Jobe in the middle and had enough cash to upgrade Hargrave to Adcock at the back. So to answer ur question....BOTH!

If i had to choose 1 tho i'd take Broughton

[underdog11]

JADCOCK! i heard that vossy's planning midfield time from s super secret source  ;), another reason im not touching golby

[Windigo]

If Jedi is playing midfield. It should free up Golby to rebound?  ???

[sammy]

cheers guys :)

thanks for the link FlipFlops, i wish i had the money to upgrade Hargrave to one of them!

I haven't though about Hanley, i just dont trust him for some reason

and yeah, i noticed Jedcock was named in the centre this week and if he stays there he can score big. it'd be good if we knew who was going to stay in the mids for most games this year

[arzbar96]

Broughton 13.7 percent, Adcock 5 percent picked..

[sammy]

id Jedcock can stay uninjured you'd think he'd play a fair bit in the mids, but when Mundy and maybe even Morabito get back Broughton might be sent back to defence. i'm leaning slightly towards Broughton because of Jedcock's injury history

[Windigo]

Cross fingers Broughton still rolls through the midfield. Dawson down back may be a blessing in disguise....

[Holz]

id Jedcock can stay uninjured you'd think he'd play a fair bit in the mids, but when Mundy and maybe even Morabito get back Broughton might be sent back to defence. i'm leaning slightly towards Broughton because of Jedcock's injury history

broughton going to defence isnt even always a negative, he score well as the rebounding defender aswell, we just dont want the lockdown defender and i cant see lyon doing that. Freo had lots of back injuries last year to go with the mid, so I think they should have ebnough guys in the lockdown role, it really depends who gets injured and who stays fit.

[me]

JADCOCK! i heard that vossy's planning midfield time from s super secret source  ;), another reason im not touching golby

wouldn't adcock being more in the mids be more of a reason to get golby? means he gets the rebounding role lol ---- its not like golby was going to be playing mids anyway

btw, probs should add HEP D to the poll, he's flying right under the radar at the moment but will gun it this season through the mids/slutty back

[Kuruki]

I have Broughts and Adcock. Im seriously looking at dumping Shaw and Getting Heppel also.

[Zombie2.5]

Yep broughts for sure hoping he plays that gun mid spot.
Would love to Gravy>Adcock though, good OOP(out of position) player as hes a defender playing in mids(hopefully)
i had adcock but just had to go to broughts with his NAB and new coach = hopefully mid role