What would you do?

Started by Chopps, April 12, 2012, 02:01:28 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Chopps

What would you do with this team? I know don't trade is an option so give me a different opinion.
I am fairly confident in my team for now, I like to explore any and all options this is where you come in, any feedback or suggestions to improve my side is appreciated.

Cash: $5,800
Rd 1: 2185
Rd 2: 2166

Backs: Goddard, lids, shaw,waters, Hargave, Clarke, bugg (Ellis, Morris)
Mids; ablett,swan,selwood,rockliff,McCarthy, magner (coniglio, shiel)
Ruck: cox, giles (redden, Stephenson )
Forwards: buddy, fyfe, Martin, sidebottom, dangerfield,Kennedy d.smith(pfeiffer, couch)

Thoughts?

T Dog

Me? I would be looking at the benefit of Coniglio on the bench. Is he a real emergency in your plan or are you hoping he will generate cash? May be better uses of his value before the rises this week. Its more of an issue to move his cash to your forward line as it is a 2 trade action.
So I would be holding fire this week and see what other hurdles shake out over the next few weeks. ;D it is only rd 3 after all.

Chopps

Thank for the feedback, I am currently not trading unless I come up with an option.
Coniglio was ment to be m6 but due to magma has fallen to m7

I may need to move pfeiffer and that would be to milera.
Couch should debut shortly and got picked as I wasn't willing to sacralise my other rooks to get one worth more for couch (I missed rd1 teams)

Coniglio poses an issue though as I won't hold him to rd 11 anyways

Justin Bieber

Cox might not play. Are you willing to play Spud Redden?

upthemaidens

may aswell trade 5fer if he doesnt get named, and grab a cash cow

Spite

No wonder we are scoring so similar chopps, we have 4 players different! :P Nearly the exact same mid too with the exception of coniglio

Andrew

Pfeiffer -> Milera is a pretty safe trade for you for this round. If you're worried about Shaw then move him on for Birchall, but you had to be prepared for the rollercoaster if you picked him and you don't have any premos of concern otherwise.

Chopps

Quote from: Spite on April 12, 2012, 07:37:44 PM
No wonder we are scoring so similar chopps, we have 4 players different! :P Nearly the exact same mid too with the exception of coniglio

Who is different ?

Not concerned about shaw he'll be right, See what happens with maxwell back.
Cox is named so redden as E

Thinking after saying I wouldn't make the trade

Pfeiffer to milera
Coniglio to Greene






Spite

Quote from: Chopps on April 12, 2012, 02:01:28 PM
Backs: Goddard, lids, shaw,waters, Hargave, Clarke, bugg (Ellis, Morris)
Mids; ablett,swan,selwood,rockliff,McCarthy, magner (coniglio, shiel)
Ruck: cox, giles (redden, Stephenson )
Forwards: buddy, fyfe, Martin, sidebottom, dangerfield,Kennedy d.smith(pfeiffer, couch)

I have scotland and broughton instead of shaw and waters, mumford instead of cox and old mac instead of coniglio, and townsend instead of clarke, so make that 5 :P