any last minute advice guys?? would be much appreciated :D

Started by ando_10, March 29, 2012, 10:48:20 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

ando_10

backs: goddard, deledio, shaw, adcock, lake, ellis, bugg
emg: morris, bouman

mids: ablett, swan, boyd, caddy, coniglio, sheil
emg: magner, kerridge

rucks: mumford, giles
emg: redden, stephenson

forwards: franklin, goodes, fyfe, martin, sidebottom, porps, D.smith
emg: kennedy, pfeiffer

38k left

let me know :D

twinkle

Hard to fault. Not much point of difference to most teams - but safe and should do well. 

I reckon Sidebum is a good pick this year. Bouman is unknown to me

bmac25

B: Standard but solid.

M: Well balanced.  Not convinced on Caddy, but he seems to be very popular.

R: Bit late now but Mumford's tribunal record might hurt you.  If he keeps a clean sheet, could be devastating.

F: Fairly solid, interesting unique in Sidebottom.  Could pay off.

8.5/10

MC

Porp, Lake AND Caddy seems to be a fair risk. imo get another mid prem keeper (esp with 1 prem ruck) Up to you though - seems nearly as solid as possible if you're set on the one ruck option!

Marcos83

Solid backs but not sure about adcock, could downgrade and change caddy for a decent player. I say this because i initially had caddy and conoglio disappointed me.

Rucks and your forward line are solid, mix of great prems, mid pricer, and capable rookies. Chapman could come in by changing adcock to someone else and upgrade sidey to him