forgot about saad, should he get in

[egosbar]

forgot about saad he was in my side for a while , now that couch is in he can get a start in my team

i have hall weedon and couch  , should i replace weedon with saad

[Mozza3]

I don't like either to be honest but I think Saad has the better JS.

[elephants]

I would only expect 40-75 like scores from him. I'm taking the risk on Dickson + Hall.

[egosbar]

im not sold on either as well but i have to have a sevent forward if not them who

as i said i have smith hall couch , need one more yet

lot of talk on dickson , ill have to wait to see who starts

[Mozza3]

I like Dickson out of the lot by far.

[pavs nose]

don't have sadd ebcause i dont think he'll a decent ave but his job security should be ok

[Holz]

i dont see Saad being worth the extra 35-40k over couch. I hopefully will never be starting couch so im happy for him to just make cash on the bench and priced at 80k he should make lots even with average scores.

[pavs nose]

i dont see Saad being worth the extra 35-40k over couch. I hopefully will never be starting couch so im happy for him to just make cash on the bench and priced at 80k he should make lots even with average scores.

same here. i think his job should be secure until silvia returns, just in time for milking with any luck

[Tom_16]

i dont see Saad being worth the extra 35-40k over couch. I hopefully will never be starting couch so im happy for him to just make cash on the bench and priced at 80k he should make lots even with average scores.

same here. i think his job should be secure until silvia returns, just in time for milking with any luck

Sorry to burst your bubble but Sylvia is expected to return in round 4
http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/7415/newsid/131688/default.aspx

[Phasir]

I find it hard to believe he'll get any more than 5 matches this year unless Milne, Schnieder and some small midfielders go down early in the season, much better options, Kennedy, Zorko, Hall, Pfieffer, Smith, Couch etc