Rate My Team And Il Rate Yours! Thanks!

[PommyPirate]

Hi all,

Another season. Thoughts and ratings welcomed please.

Backs: Goddard, Scotland, Deledio, Fisher, Broughton, Bugg, Morris (Mohr, Ellis)

Mids: GAJ, Boyd, D Smith, Shiel, C Smith, Mcdonald (Pffifer, Magner)

Rucks: Cox, Giles (Stephenson, Reddan)

Forwards: Franklin, Chapman, Fyfe, Pavlich, Martin, N Roo, A Kennedy (Hall, Kerridge)

Thanks.

[bkp130]

B- i like them a lot. I was thinking of scotland in my team but dont know if he can justify his price tag this season. The rest look really good
M- Pretty similar to mine but i dont have any premiums i have all rookies. I like the choice of Garry and Boyd though
R- good picks again.
F- I like them all except n roo instead of him i personally would get sidebottom and he is cheaper

Overall good team. You should go pretty well depending on your trade stratergy Overall 9/10

If you can can you rate my team? I am going with 8 rookie midfielders and Premium backs and Fowards. Its going to be an interesting experiment to see how it goes. Thanks in advance. the link is Below

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,52912.0.html

[tor01doc]

Like it except a bit gun shy in the mids.

Maybe Danger up front instead of NRoo? DPP and easy draw to start. Hard to see him drop in price and has a high ceiling.

Also better from a bye point of view.

If you had Bugg, McDonald and Kennedy on the field, no Goodes, Malceski or Mummy then the car is almost yours anyway so don't worry.

[SAMCRO]

Have you thought about the byes? Goddard, Scotland, Deledio, Fisher, Morris and Ellis all have the bye in round 13 which would leave your backline completely destroyed that week.

[tor01doc]

Yes but rookies will be gone by then I assume. If not, then they are either firing or you are in all sorts of trouble.
I would lose one of the round 13 bye guns and add Shaw.

Bye

[lowry]

nice backs and forwards!!

B i think scotland is overpriced and better of with shaw;
M mids are a lilttle weak but u can compensate in the forwards and backs
R no problem
F nice

9/10

can u rate mine, its a little different to yours
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php?topic=53320.0

[PommyPirate]

Thanks for the comments. I came in the top 750 last season so hoping for a repeat.

Why do a few of you say Scotland is over priced? He is a gun, underated and durable in a good side?!

Shaw is risky with his off field behaviour, if he stays away from the TAB and the Melbourne Bitter he might be ok but you never know whe youl suddenly have him missing for 5 weeks for doing something stupid.

[lowry]

I chose shaw as since leon davis left, he may get extra stats whereas scotland may slow down this year as he's getting older so his price may fall