Main Menu

Combos!

Started by gillies, March 28, 2012, 10:48:45 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which is better?

Birchall, broughton, montagna and clay smith
3 (18.8%)
scotland, Boyd, caddy and marty clarke
13 (81.3%)

Total Members Voted: 0

gillies

I have two mid spots and two back spots. Which is better option?

Justin Bieber

It looks like the bottom options looks the better of the two.

Alka

Birchall 95, Broughton 95, Montagna 110, Clay Smith (70?) = 370

Scotland 100, Boyd 120, Caddy 90, Clarke 70 = 380

Second option seems better, and is safer.
However, I voted for option 1. Riskier, but a bigger potential upside.
I actually think Montagna will do better than 110, his '09 avg was 115 and '10 was 112.
Last year he had some injury affected scores. Plus Hayes is back this year. He's hitting his peak in terms of age. I'd back him in myself, but he doesn't fit my structure (have 4 super premo's).

Broughton could get moved around, but provided he keep his NAB cup role, he will go above a 95 average and dominate.

Clay Smith I'm really not sure about, however I doubt he'd be on your field anyway? Consider Neale too.

Justin Bieber

^ Montagna to average 110? Are you serious?

Caddy 90 is a bit high...

Boyd won't average 120. Only one person ever as averaged that high...

Alka

Quote from: whatlez on March 28, 2012, 12:45:24 PM
^ Montagna to average 110? Are you serious?

Caddy 90 is a bit high...

Boyd won't average 120. Only one person ever as averaged that high...

Based on his previous years, and a good pre-season, yeah, 110 is perfectly viable.

I expect Boyd to improve on last years average ever so slightly in an improving and more DT friendly side. Maybe not 120, but certainly in the 116-118 range.

Caddy maybe not, I don't rate him as highly as others on here, just giving a general perspective. If you bump him down to 85, and Boyd to 116, option 1 is even more temtping.

Bak2Form

poll says it all mate