is this backline too risky?

[rizza1]

Is this backline to risky?
i know theres 4 mid pricers including Clarke but they are all proven scores and will make a lot of $
Delidio, Goddard, Dempsey, Lake, Hargrave, Clarke and Bugg?

[meow meow]

If you have to ask, you already know.

[rizza1]

If you have to ask, you already know.

But it could work and be very good

[HotTiges]

geez i would say too risky.. you'd want 1 maybe 2 max of that lot. Lake is fairly proven SC scorer, Hargrave had 1 good year a while back and I don't rate Dempsey in SC anymore and everyone's doubting Marty Clarke on here.. ya must of loaded up elsewhere?? too many mid pricers for my liking

[Tainey]

I thought I was taking a big risk having Dempsey & Clarke in my backline. Adding Lake and Hargrave to that list is as risky as visiting a 17yr old school girl in her hotel and being filmed in your underwear.

[rizza1]

geez i would say too risky.. you'd want 1 maybe 2 max of that lot. Lake is fairly proven SC scorer, Hargrave had 1 good year a while back and I don't rate Dempsey in SC anymore and everyone's doubting Marty Clarke on here.. ya must of loaded up elsewhere?? too many mid pricers for my liking

yeah i've got a good midfield and forwards, i think i'm going to keep lake and Clarke, and get another premium in there

[HotTiges]

dempsey to rookie(named) and hargrave to premo

[specky lecky]

NO!! don't like the structure. loose 2 of your 4 medium pricers, and replace with one premium and 1 cheap rookie

[Perthwildcat]

Sometimes you gotta risk it to get the biscuit.

Go with your gut man, if you don't pick these players and they kill it, you will hate yourself.

[fever]

you'd be lucky to get crumbs from the buscuit with that line

[devize]

I wouldn't have Dempsey, has never had good SC scores (best average 77) and has played only 28 games in 5 years. It's too late now but I would have replaced him with Malceski, absolute gun we he's fit and showed he scores well even in a poor performance.

Hargrave hasn't been a good SC scorer in the past but his role seems to have changed this year and could be a good pick.

Lake is a proven SC scorer and his injury problems seem a thing of the past. He should atleast get you 80-85+ average and could very well get back to his old scoring ways. I'd lock him in.

I'd probably either get rid of Dempsey for a rookie and spend the money elsewhere or get rid of both Dempsey and Hargrave for a premium and leaving Lake and Clarke in there.

[meow meow]

Lake will take half a year to be back to his old self.

[SydneyRox]

NO!! don't like the structure. loose 2 of your 4 medium pricers, and replace with one premium and 1 cheap rookie

+1