Can my team hold its own? Please lend a hand.

[JamesHarden13]

Backs; Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Birchall, Lake, Ellis, Mohr (Bugg, Tynan)

Mids; Pendlebury, Ablett, Murphy, A.Swallow, Hogan, Magner (Ledger, Shiel)

Rucks; Mumford, Giles (Redden, Stephenson)

Forwards; Franklin, Fyfe, Martin, Cloke, Porplyzia, D.Smith, Saad (Hall, Dickson)

3k leftover!
Need a hand, not sure if it stands up to the other teams on here, please calm me down and convince me otherwise! haha.
Leave a link and I'll rate yours!
All rates, suggestions, etc are appreciated !

[tor01doc]

No takers?

3 byes R13 in defence. Typical though.

Like the selections here. Keep.

Pendles - a lot of money up front.Your call.

A Swallow - will he become a top 8 or so - if not get him out - get Swan for Pendles, use the money to upgrade to Boyd?

Mumford will only score about 8 more than Giles so don't make him captain.

F fine.

[bkp130]

Hey mate

B- Really good
M- Once again pretty good. Not sur ebaout hogan but the rest are good.Especially like the pick of swallow as a unique pick
r- pretty standard in most team but could be a solid contribution
f- Once again really good but not sure how much game time saad will get.

Overall i would say 8.5-9/10

If you get a chance can you rate my team. I am trying a 8 rookie midfield team with premium defenders, rucks and fowards
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,52912.0.html

thanks mate

[JamesHarden13]

Cheers lads!
But nah mate, Pendlebury and Swallow are off limits to be traded as I reckon both will lift their average as hard as that will be for pendles to do considering his huge year last year!
But thanks for all the feedback!
Keep the feedback flowing boys!

And I'll get onto your unique side soon champ.

[johnnytheboy1]

Backs: Excellent  4 Premiums. good selection of rookie in Mohr scored 86sc points which you should be happy about.
Mids: Very strong good to have 4 premium mids.If you like Swallow keep him in your team.As for Hogan time will tell.
Rucks: Mumford wasn't fantastic against GWS but still scored 95sc points. Giles can only improve facing Goldstein in Round 2.
Fwds: Excellent fwds should score real well.

Overall  JamesHarden13 your team HAS 13 Premiums which is fantastic i give you an 8.5/10

[JamesHarden13]

Thanks mate, appreciate the feedback and I believe Simon hogan will be one of the est buys this year so he's staying!