McIntosh & Porps vs Giles & Pavlich (plus little downgrade)

[billnats]

Hey Guys,
Which team looks better?

Team 1 has McIntosh in Ruck & Porps in the forward line
Team 2 has Rookie on field and some little downgrades to include Pavlich up forward

Team 1



Team 2

[wardie]

Wouldn't be confident on playing 2 rooks in the fwd line. I would rather cash in BOYD/SWALLOW play CONIGILO in the mids and upgrade COUCH/PFIFFER to a premium such as DANGER.

[hawki]

2nd option has 1 more premo.. think boyd will outscore dangerfield.

[wardie]

2nd option has 1 more premo.. think boyd will outscore dangerfield.

He may but I would rather the stability and JS of DANGER over a rookie i.e. COUCH. CONGILINO will score more than any of the rookies that will play in the forward line.

[billnats]

Well I can:
- team 1: downgrade shaw to birchall and bring in coniglio into mids
- team 2: bring pavlich into side as previously shown by downgrading Mcintosh