Demon Vs Demon

[TheHanger]

I have Magner but Couch is making me wonder

[Notorious P.I.G.]

Magner has been elevated to senior list, performed in the NAB cup and should play most of the season... nothing yet on couch's rookie status changing, so kind of makes the decision for you?

[Mr.Craig]

As well he should, not eligble to play. You can't go into the season with a bloke like that. If he gets elevated next week it will all change of course and everyone will probably jump on.

[Zombie2.5]

Yep Magners elevated, recovered better than expected, prolly play rd 1.
Couch is still rookie listed and melbourne DONT have to upgrade, also on afl website melb said they are in no rush to elevate rooks just because there are spots.

So couch for a downgrade target(there seems to be alot, lets hope they play their first games at diff times)

[Justin Bieber]

Magnet all day baby haha ::)

[ShyOne]

Magner having been elevated should increase value earlier. For me, considering his NAB form, should increase in value quicker, and potentially become a keeper, where as at the moment Couch is more hype than anything else.