Quick Poll: M.Clarke, P.Bower, Guthrie

Started by mpollock, March 25, 2012, 04:04:52 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who would you pick out of Clarke, Bower and Guthrie?

M.Clarke
7 (36.8%)
P.Bower
4 (21.1%)
Guthrie
8 (42.1%)

Total Members Voted: 2

Voting closed: April 01, 2012, 03:04:52 PM

mpollock

Who is the best pick at this price range ... Clarke, Bower or Guthrie?

charliesheen

All of them have question marks.  Guthrie probably has the best job security, but I could be wrong.

P.Bower has the highest ceiling... but I have NFI what to make of him.

mpollock

If MM instead of Bucks was still in charge then M.Clarke would have great JS.
Not sure on how Bucks sees him ... as a key player in their best 22 or as a depth player only.

Mozza3

Bucks was the reason why Clarke came back. Apparently Clarke and Malthouse had a falling out, hence why he returned to Ireland.

mpollock

Good to know Mozza ... I wasn't aware of that ... gives me even more confidence in starting with M.Clarke.
From the poll ... guthrie is in front ...

But it is Clarke for me ... if he doesn't play i get 100 from Bugg anyway for rd 1.

meow meow

Number 29 from Geelong and Supercoach mix well.