The Fyfe Dilemma

Started by Adamant, March 23, 2012, 12:16:29 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who to trade for Fyfe?

Lance Franklin
4 (10.3%)
Adam Goodes
5 (12.8%)
Mitch Robinson
25 (64.1%)
Dustin Martin
1 (2.6%)
Steele Sidebottom
0 (0%)
Dont start with Fyfe, keep your Fwd line.
4 (10.3%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Adamant

Looking through some peoples teams most people have Nat Fyfe locked as 2nd/3rd FWD. While I love Avatar and think he is an absolute gun I just dont see him really improving on his 98 point avg with extra attention and his dodgy shoulders this year(and Im a freo supporter). Does anyone else have these thoughts? Or should I just lock him in as he should still easily be a top 7 fwd?

Current FWD line:
Franklin, Goodes, Robinson, Martin, Sidebottom, D.Smith, Kennedy (Pfieffer, Dickson)

Is it worth dropping one of the above fwd's to make room for Avatar?
Dont worry about the Byes when selecting your option.
Cheers

lolrocket

This is his 3rd year and he already avgs 98, his form in NAB has been awesome. Your forward line is very solid without him though. I'd personally take out Robinson

Mr.Craig

I don't see many of the top forwards increasing their average by much this year, even with the addition of another easybeat team. You could take him over Robinson, probably not much difference in what they'll average but Fyfe will be more enjoyable to own I reakon.

Jukes

Don't like robinson. Like the others. /obvious

specky lecky

I have all of your premiums except robinson. I would take fyfe if you can squeeze him in somehow. Jordan lewis or gray are also good options in my opinion

RiOtChEsS

if u dont care about the bye then ditch Robbo...

if u do it has to be Goodes or Sidebum...

D.Zanetti

I think the Poll shouts out our answer  8)

Chopps

if you dont want to take out robinson, take out goodes you can always upgrade to goodes and i wouldnt think he will improve much on his 99 avg