help appreciated

[wvogue]

Which is better?

BACKS: birhcall, Deledio, Shaw, Yarran, Hargrave, Dempsey, Ellis (Smedts, Bugg)
MIDS: Boyd, Murphy, Bartel, Cotchin, Caddy, Sheil (Hampton, Mcdonald)
RUCKS: Kreuzer, Maric, Giles, Redden
FWDS: Franklin, Martin, Cloke, Zaharakis, Dangerfeild, D.Smith, Saad (Pfeiffer, Dickson)

                                            OR


BACKS: Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Yarran, Hargrave, Dempsey, Ellis (Smedts, Bugg)
MIDS: Ablett, Murphy, Bartel, Cotchin, J.Mccarthy, Sheil (hampton, Mcdonald)
RUCKS: Kreuzer, Giles, Redden, Big O
FWDS: Franklin, Martin, Cloke, Zaharakis, Dangerfeild, D.Smith, Saad (Pfeiffer, Dickson)