GILES and BROGAN

[GWS4flag]

I have MUMMY and GILES as starting rucks. With Redden and Stephenson on the bench.

I figure Mummy will smash Redden and O.Stephenson is listed as starting.

I am thinking with GILES listed to start at FF should i START Stephenson and Bench Giles as my EMERGENCY?

I'm a first year supercoacher...will this give me more points potentially?

[jabroni]

stephenson is still an unknown quantity so to speak so i would go with giles this week

[esquire]

That idea is about as bad as that photo of yours!!! Start Mummy and Giles and leave Redden and the big O on the pine. Brogan is a candidate for the vest in his first game back. What I would be worried about is if Mummy actually plays. First time in ages Seaby is an emergency and it tells me the Swans aren't confident Mummy will get up for this one.

[nathan11]

Everyone said mummy would smash giles too  big o has scored 18 points and couldn't get up for last weeks game no way should you start him