Wingnut's Final Side - Rate for Rate

[WP Wingnuts]

Defs; Goddard, Shaw, Deledio, Duffman, Golby, Lake, Ellis (Bugg, Morris)
Mids; Pendlebury, Boyd, Ablett (C), Thommo (VC), Coniglio, Magner (C. Smith, Shiel)
Rucks; Mumford, Giles (Redden, Stephensen)
Fwds; Chappy, Franklin, Fyfe, Martin, Dangerfield, D. Smith, Kennedy (Hall, Dickson)
Cash Rem; $2,300

I've got a few target trades that will help with the bye situation but I'm not too concerned about it at this stage, who knows what could happen between now and round 11!

Any thoughts on the line up?
Cheers!

[jamez_1983]

Not bad.
IMO there is too much risk in defence.
im not sold on duffman or golby.
i also dont think its necessary to waste a mid spot on a dpp link with the new trade system.
if you want pfeiffer maybe put him forward at the expense of Hall.
Golby> Clarke and use the change to upgrade duffman to broughton.

thoughts/suggestions on mine?

DEF: Scotland, Goddard, Deledio, Broughton, MClarke, Ellis, Bugg (Smedts, Morris
MID: Ablett, Boyd, Selwood, S.Thompson, Coniglio , Magner ( Shiel , Gibson)
RUC: Cox , Giles (Redden, Stephenson)
FWD: Franklin, Fyfe, Goodes , Martin, Dangerfield, Porplyzia, D.Smith ( A.Kennedy , Pfeiffer)

$43,000 left over

Again, also not worried about byes with rookies as most will be gone by then.

[WP Wingnuts]

At first look, the Duffield/Golby inclusions look risky but IMO Duffman will smoke it this year, under Lyon's game plan his defenders have always scored well and aside from last year, his ave is usually up between 80-90. Golby will play every week he's fit and has been killing it in the NAB, I'm backing him in. I'm more worried about the JS of Clarke, IMO he isn't in the pies best 22 and for his price I think thats actually alot riskier.
I would like to keep Hall & Dickson as emergencies in the fwds, and have considered Gibson over Pfeiffer but I'm going to wait until the teams are named.

I think you've got a solid side there, obviously our difference in opinion in regards to defence has been mentioned previously. I'm worried about Scotlands court case, but in saying that, Shaw will probably have one at some stage this year aswell knowing him haha. Love the Thommo inclusion, with such a soft draw this year he was too good to refuse. Your rucks are great, I hope to upgrade to Cox at some stage this year. Solid forwards, I'm not sold on Danger as he's burnt me before but I can see why people pick him. Good luck mate, I think you're in for a good year!

[Tyes]

Great team mate, I really enjoy seeing 5 premos in that Fwd line, looks really nice. I like the back too, if you're going to be risky anywhere this season it has to be there. Golby just may be the Suckling of 2012. ;)

[WP Wingnuts]

Just updated my side, with any luck I'll leave it be and lock it in!