Rate this 14 Premium Team & I will rate yours

[Dilen9]

Backline :
B Goddard, B Deledio, H Shaw,  G.Broughton, B.Ellis, B.Smedts, T.Bugg ( L.Spurr, L Brown )

Midfeild :
G Ablett, D Swan, J Selwood, S Thompson, A.Miles, J.Magner (E.Kavanagh , S.Gibson )

Rucks :
S.Mumford, B.Mcevoy ( J Giles, J.Reddan )

Fowards :
L Franklin, M Pavlich, A Goodes, D Martin, D.Smith, S.Kerridge, G Weedon ( D.Pfeiffer ,T.Couch)

Salary Cap $18300

DEF: Very strong, but maybe too much rookies. Other than that, it is a very good defense.
MID: great midfield. Love the choice of thompson, did u see his fixture? Very good choice of rookies.
RCK: brilliant, but maybe you should choose someone else, instead of McEvoy. Mumford will have a big season.
FWD: ahpgain, it is good, but too much rookies. Other than that it is good.
OVERALL: A very solid team, I would give you a 8/10.

[Bigheat]

Backline :
B Goddard, B Deledio, H Shaw,  G.Broughton, B.Ellis, B.Smedts, T.Bugg ( L.Spurr, L Brown )

Midfeild :
G Ablett, D Swan, J Selwood, S Thompson, A.Miles, J.Magner (E.Kavanagh , S.Gibson )

Rucks :
S.Mumford, B.Mcevoy ( J Giles, J.Reddan )

Fowards :
L Franklin, M Pavlich, A Goodes, D Martin, D.Smith, S.Kerridge, G Weedon ( D.Pfeiffer ,T.Couch)

Salary Cap $18300

Solid Team
Backs - All good (Will Smedts play?)
Mids - Starters are great. Keep a watchful eye on the rookies you have picked.
Rucks - Reality is you will need Big Cox at some point to be competitive. Ditch McEvoy as you have picked him as a keeper no doubt for a rookie or upgrade to Cox.
Forwards - Great. Can you squeeze fyfe in instead of Pav?

[Swaino]

BACKS - nice mix of premiums and rookies..
MIDS - 3 of the best mids going round, nice choice of rookies..
RUCKS - nice to see someone going with 2 premium rucks, rather than the 1 premium and 3 rookie rucks..
FWDS - look good, but maybe one too many rookies? might have to sacrifice a premium mid to upgrade a rookie in the fwd line..

overall nice looking side

8.5/10

[Dilen9]

Backs: H. Scotland, B. Deledio, B. Goddard, M. Suckling, B. Lake, M. Clarke, B. Ellis.
Subs: B. Smedts, T. Mohr.

Mids: G. Ablett, J. Selwood, T. Rockliff, S. Clifton, T. Mitchell, J. Magner.
Subs: L. Brown, S. Kerridge.

Rucks: S. Mumford, J. Giles.
Subs: J. Redden, O. Stephensen

Forwards: L. Franklin, C. Rioli, A. Goodes, N. Fyfe, D. Martin, D. Smith, C. Hampton.

Subs: A. Hall, D. Pfeiffer.

Thoughts?

Backs: Looks solid with Suckling at D4 not sure whether Smedts will get much game time early on in the season as Guthrie is ahead of him.
Mids: Good choice of Premiums.Mitchell is probably a better bench option as he hasn't played in any NAB CUP games.
Rucks: Giles looks like he will be No1Ruck in round 1 as Brogan is in doubt due to injury. So he is looking a better pick to start.
Fwds: Very solid with good depth Having Martin at F5 is a Bonus.


Overall You have a terrific team it has plenty of Guns and should be highly competitive. I give you an 8.5/10

Hey, mate, thanks for rating my team.
DEF: good, but hy would you have Clarke, plenty of other rookies for a way cheaper price that would get the same score as Marty.
MID: good, nice choice of premiums.
RCKS: good
FWD:love it, it's great.
OVERALL: very ice, should bring you very far this season. Well some 9/10

[johnnytheboy1]

That is my revised team

Backs Goddard,Deledio,Shaw,Broughton,Malceski,Ellis,T.Bugg (Darley,Smedts)
Mids: Ablett,Rockliff,Selwood , J.Caddy ,C.Smith, T.Ledger (D.Smith,Magner)
Rucks: Cox,Giles (Stephenson,Redden)
Fwds: Franklin Goodes,Fyfe,Martin,Dangerfield J.Porplyzia,Kennedy (S.Kerridge,j.Cameron)

Salary Cap $105000

Please rate this team
I have swapped Mcdonald with Ledger
   

[Babylove]

That looks like a good team.  I normally go through each line but there isn't much to say.  Not sure about having three crows in the forward line but that's mostly nitpicking.  You do have a few rookies that need elevating to the senior list at their respective clubs so watch out for that.  Otherwise looks like a good team.

Could you have a look at my team when you get a chance:
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,51808.0.html