caddy, parker or mcCarthy?

Started by BBosCo, March 20, 2012, 12:48:48 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

caddy, parker or mcCarthy?

Caddy
5 (23.8%)
Parker
4 (19%)
McCarthy
12 (57.1%)

Total Members Voted: 0

BBosCo

keen on peoples opinion on these three mid pricers

Ricochet

at the moment i have Mccarthy, will the others have the same JS?

Jukes

Toss up for me between McCarthy and Masten, have McCarthy atm but will change a few times in the next week and a bit.

Mr.Craig

McCarthy's JS is rock solid and he'll score reasonably well. I can see him going up in value about 100k.

Parker played half a season last year and was sub 5 times which butchered his DT average. He proved he could score a ton (107 vs Gold Coast) and has been good in the pre season. So, just a matter of him taking his opportunities early on and avoiding more vests.

Caddy also showed his class with a blistering 89 point game against the Hawks last year. JS looks as good as it can be but he is the most inexperienced of the 3.

My head says McCarthy, my heart says Parker and my balls say Caddy.

BBosCo

hmm im allmost tempted to go all three, works well with my structure. doubt i will have the balls though

fertalong

For scoring potential I would say Caddy, but he could be the victim of a vest. McCarthy has highest JS and will avg similar anyway, so he's the safer option.

Colliwobblers

parker caddy mcarthy for scoring potential

cadyy last for js in vest issues as mentioned above the other two are locks in thier sides but caddy "should" be also

ive been locked on caddy for awhile but the one that impresses me most lately is parker

ShaynoB

Provided McCarthy plays full games then I reckon he good easily avg 88+... Not so sure the other 2 will avg quite that much

Justin Bieber

All are good uniques, where you could get burnt or pay off very well.

mezzoculo

Swans have a 'delicious' early draw and the Round 12 bye.
Those with the courage to play Parker could use this to bring in a Round 11 premium in his place with little extra cash.