A few mid pricers, give me your thoughts!

Started by Cunno, March 14, 2012, 08:47:45 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cunno

DEF: Goddard, Heppell, Deledio, Adcock, Hargrave, Clarke, Ellis (Smedts, Bugg)

MID: Ablett, Murphy, Thompson, Masten, Clifton, Miles ( Stevens, Kerridge)

RUCK: Cox, Jacobs (Giles, Redden)

FWD: Franklin, Pavlich, Martin, Sidebottom, Christensen, Porplyzia, Skinner (Couch, D.Smith)

Money in the bank: $87,000

any help would be greatly appreciated!

its me lads

DEF: I'm not keen on Adcock but he will probably do well. Marty Clarke was popular but he hasn't shown much during the Nab cup and he has know left my side.

MID: Masten is a risky pick but if you want him go for it. Instead of Kerridge maybe Clay Smith would be a better rookie.

RUCK: Lovely rucks

FWD: I don't think you should get Christensen this year but its up to you. Skinner is also a player i would stay away from.

7.5/10. not too bad.

Cunno

Thanks for the input mate,
who would you suggest instead of adcock? i had lids but he his lack of NAB cup action has me a bit worried about his fitness
I'm a fan of masten, not quite sure why, just got a gut feeling i guess ahah, kerridge is there purely for his DPP, is that going to be such an issue this year you reckon?
and yeah im not 100% on him either, ballantyne/dangerfield good replacements?

its me lads

i also had lids but his no nab cup games put me off him. Broughton is a good option in my opinion. He has been playing midfield all nab cup and his potential is massive, rossy lyon seems to like him in the midfield. another in that price range is houli, unique but i like him.

yeah go with your gut. sorry before, kerridge will be a fine option, i was thinking of a different bloke but kerridge got 1.0 and 10 touches as sub brought on in Q3 so thats fairly solid to stick with. DPP necessity is up to u i guess.

both are good. personally i have dangerfield and ballantyne isnt doing too bad either, he is playing midfield whichs is a good thing.
i also have mitch clark on my watchlist who is around that price tag. if richmond keep playing well then even jack reiwoldt could be an option, he booted 4 goals on the weekend with 15 possys.

leathermad

DEF: Adcock is a gun Lids underdone look to upgrade after bye. Clarke also needs more time

MIDS: Unique. Masten risky but if he lives up to it good for you. If not Masten how about Gaff??

RUCKS: Dont trust the 1 premo 3 rookie strategy..Well done there

FWDS: Same thoughts as "its me lads"

Cunno

yeah as its me lads said i might look at broughts, hopefully he can get lots of time in the middle

i liked the look of him too, but if he doesnt get a game round 1 ill switch him out for somebody else and hopefully pick him up later

just brought in dangerfield and porps, hoping porps can get back to his best and at 200k its not really that big of a risk if he cant, and dangerfield is just looking that good i couldnt ignore him. nah ive got too many key forwards for my liking as it is hahah ;)

Zombie2.5

I like the Adcock choice and i had him too, just had to squeeze him out because he dint fit structure and hes got a good bye too.
But if you dont want him, broughts is good, otherwise you could always go to one of those mid pricers then upgrade christensen or danger to a gun.

i reckon robbie gray can be a good replacement for christensen if you can afford.

I personally dont like masten either, same as other guys