Close to starting line up thoughts pls

[tiger_1]

B. Goddard, Scotland, Deliedo, Hargrave, Guthrie, Ellis, Townsend (Newell, Turnbridge)
M. Ablett, Swan, Judd, Boyd, Pridis, Stevens (Stringer, McDonald)
R. Cox, Giles (Redden, Stevenson)
F. Franklin, Fyfe, Johnson, Tippett, Tomlinson, Smith, Pfiffer (Dixon, Couch)

17k left in the bank. What do you think? rating out of 10

[tiger_1]

Come On guys give my something please

[dickitch]

I'm not sure about Judd there, from research it seems that people favour Murphy - seems to be more consistent.

And as i just said on my team - i'm not sure about Scotland either, Shaw may be a better option and slightly cheaper

[Ringo]

You have gone very heavy on the mids at the expense of other lines. Past experience has also established that the best cash cows are mid rookies and with your selections you are limiting possible cash gains eg Teams going with a 3 mid start may be able to finalise their teams a lot quicker. Not a lot of impressive rookie backs at the moment so I would be looking to put another prem in there by downgrading one of your mids.
Most teams will be going in with 4 prem defenders but you only have 3. Same with forward line but Tippett may become a prem.
With Rookies just make sure you select those that are playing in round 1.

Bit harsh with rating of 7/10 but due to weak forward and def lines,

[tiger_1]

Thanks for that guys. Something to think about. Anybody else got some advice

[bradw]

yeah have to agree, too many prem mids - you only need 3 or 4.  You need one more prem in back and fwd line