the 3 Mid Price MIDS - have your say

[essendon2]

Everyone has read these articles before about the players who are in the price range of 200k-300k, but we're getting down to the last 7 days until partial lockout, and as there are no more NAB cup games - I don't know who to pick!!

John McCarthy 251k:
Has moved from old club Collingwood to new club Port Adelaide and seems to be dominating. his last 3 games read as 99 (shortened game), 66 (from a half) and 64 (from a half) - thats absolutely awesome, but why does he keep getting subbed off?! I'm worried he'll continuously be the sub even though I sub consciously think he won't be!

Josh Caddy 249k:
Played only the two games in season '11 and averaged 73. He's in red hot form scoring 66 (from a half) and 88 (from 3 quarters) in his two NAB Cup games! Gold Coast have a round 13 bye as well, which is good as there aren't many premium MIDS missing the same round, besides Ablett, Mitchell and Murphy.

Chris Masten 278k:
Has been the most promising out of the three and has the biggest potential but Eagles' MID is just two good for him with the likes of Priddis, Shuey, Embley, Rosa, A.Selwood and S.Selwood in the centre before him! But he's so tempting with scores of 47 (from a half), 87 (shortened game), 99 (shortened game) and 39 (from a half).

So which is the better option?
John McCarthy + 30k,
Josh Caddy + 30k
or
Chris Masten

[essendon2]

my midfield is currently:
Scott Pendlebury, Matthew Boyd, Gary Ablett, Jobe Watson, ________, James McDonald (Kerridge, Magner)

[Crows84]

voted cady as his the most tempting option imo

[Windigo]

Jumping ship with Masten already?  :P

[essendon2]

no!
I'm definitely getting one of these 3, I just think Caddy might be a better option.
I doubt you're still on the X.Ellis train?!  ;)

[Windigo]

I'd still be on it if he was getting games in NAB.

[Justin Bieber]

I'm sure you have asked this question several times haha