Watson vs Martin vs Sloane vs Ruck upgrade

Started by Crows84, March 18, 2012, 01:21:37 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which option would give the best value?

Watson + 23k
6 (42.9%)
Martin + 73k
3 (21.4%)
Sloane + 86k
0 (0%)
Go a rookie and upgrade Hmac to a premium
5 (35.7%)
None of the above
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Crows84

mid structure is now a Prem, Prem, Prem, Prem ......, rookie (rookie, rookie). who should i go with?  also would 5 prem mids be too many?

Ruck is currently Prem, Hmac rookie rookie

Colliwobblers

Voted to upgrade HMac, Goldy will get most of the ruck time and Petrie will get at least half of the bombs into the FWD line.

Still I am a fan of the 1+3 ruck strategy this season given Giles potential and I think Redden and even big O will improve a lot with senior games under thier belts.

5 premiums would be too many, you miss out on all the best cashcows in the mids then could hurt your team late in the season even tho it would get you off to a great start.

If you don't upgrade HMac, I'd still stick to 4 mid premiums max and use the cash in fwd or def.

Crows84

Thanks, im slowly warming to the 1+3 ruck structure and may end up going with it. appreciate the feedback :)