Paul Chapman

[NMFC8]

Is he too risky with his age

[felsty]

is goodes to risky at his age?

[elephants]

I would rather upgrade to Chappy. Someone like D. Smith could be a straight swap come round 10... :o

As for Goodes I would say start with him OR upgrade to him after his bye. He has an good start to the year but also a very good back-end of the year record... I am not on the great man but he is straight in my team come round 13!!

[Jukes]

I'd rather Chappy then some of the other older premiums such as Goodes and Pavlich.