Rate for a rate

[thesaber05]

G'day guys,
been playing around with this team for a whole but havent posted it for feedback yet, so here it is, my biggest issue at the moment is the rucks.  I'll try to give my thoughts on your teams after as well.

Backs: Scotland, Goddard, Delideo, Birchal, Hargrave, M Clarke, Ellis (Bugg, Spurr

Mids: Swan, Boyd, Watson, Ebert, Wingard, Shiel (Stevens, Magner)

Rucks: Sandi, Smith, (Redden, Stephenson)

Forwards: Johnson, Buddy, Fyfe, Martin, Dangerfield, Zorko, Cameron (Saad, Dell'Oio)

[its me lads]

DEF: Clarke hasn't shown much nab cup but otherwise all good.

MID: i dont like ebert at all and if you even need a bit of extra cash then you could do wingard to kerridge for example to get cash.

RUCK: wouldn't go anywhere near smith, Kruezer would be a better option or big will minson, david hale or even a 256k ivan maric.

FWD: again, if you ever need a bit of cash u could go stevie j to cloke, pav etc. good line up though

overall 7.5/10

rate mine please
DEF:Goddard, Broughton, Deledio, Scotland, Hargrave, Lake, Ellis, (Bugg, Darley)

MID: Swan, Ablett, Watson, Van Berlo, Smith, Magner, (Miles, Mcdonald)

RUCK: COX, Giles (Redden, Stephenson)

FWD: Franklin, Fyfe, Martin, Cloke, Dangerfield, Porplyzia, Pfiffer, (Smedts, Couch)

cash left $29k

[turry17]

Backs: Really solid line mate, sit on that to r1

Mids: If ur going for a mid pricer in mids i feel that mccarthy or caddy or even masten has showed more, try and get the cash to go watson to a super premo

Ruks: Dnt like smith, go to a Hmac/maric if looking for a midpricer then use the cash to go watson to super premo

Fowards: Good premo just not to sold on rookies. Zorko i thinks injured but if named r1 keep him, saad im not to sure on js or scoring ability and delloio i think is still rookie listed plus not to sure on js

Overall a solid team just needs a few tweaks

[thesaber05]

cheers its me lad, i'll take all of that on board
now for yours
DEF: really like the inclusion of Lake, could be a good smokie
MID: Nice smokie in Van berlo, dont like macdonald, i reckon you should spend a bit more on someone like simpkin, shiel or miles
RUCK: good, rumors that cox could be rested a few times this year but still a good choice
FWD: not sure if pfeiffer will get constant games, i reckon he will be someone who comes in only when there are injuries, i think a treloar or possibly weedon would fit better

8/10

cheers turry17, i was wondering about Zorko, people seemed to have dropped off him a bit