Final Team before round 1 please rate

Started by JimMundy93, March 13, 2012, 07:03:55 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

JimMundy93

barring an injury or a rookie not getting a round 1 selection i am happy with this team

Backs: Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Broughton, Adcock, Ellis, Bugg Yagmoor, Wilkes

Mids: Pendles, Ablett, Rockliff, Stevens, Clifton, Magner C.Smith, Shiel

Rucks: Cox, Redden Stevenson, Giles

Forwards: Buddy, Fyfe, Goodes, Martin, Danger, D.Smith, Smedts Kerridge, Treloar

What do you guys think?

JamSainter

Honestly... One of the better teams I have seen on this site to date. Only minor thing I can fault (a personal thing) don't like the 1 prem ruck but apart from that fantastic team.
Well done mate!  :)

JimMundy93

Thanks man
I wasn't sold on 1 prem ruck either
But redden is playing well enough to be a number 2 ruck and I've got a feeling he can keep it up
That's why I got him then upgraded to adcock

johnnytheboy1

Backs: Very Solid with Adcock at D5 many teams have Lake or a Rookie in that spot.
Mids: Once again strong just need Magner to hopefully play in Rd1 as he has an injury to his finger not sure whether he has been elevated.
Rucks: Redden has looked good in the Nab Cup played real well against Cox a few weeks back.Just need to jump Lobbe & Renouf to get the starting ruck. Bailey was able to do it at Hawthorn.
Fwds: Very Strong also with Dangerfield at F5.

Overall  The only thing this team dosen't have much of is uniques. Adcock maybe the only one. I still give your team an 8.5/10

tor01doc

9/10 as you have about 14 premiums (Danger and Adcock could both count depending upon your definition) and no imbalance wrt byes and donuts.

I like it.

Only suggestion is that you could consider leaving the very highly priced Pendles and Cox out until they drop (probably) and strengthen elsewhere with the savings.

Eg Save up to $91700 if you choose Swan and Mumford instead. Scores won't be massively different especially with Swans' easy draw to start.

Could select cream of the rookies or even Caddy who seems a ripper.

Nice team.

Ringo

Very strong team here.  Just need to select the right rookies who are named and will play.

Just a personal suggestion which may or may not work depending on cash you have retained is Pendles to Swan no much difference SC wise and then select Caddy in Mids or Porps in forwards both of which will score well for you.

9/10