Think im on the money! Rate for a Rate

Started by felsty, March 13, 2012, 10:26:35 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

felsty

B: Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Adcock, Lake, Ellis, Darley (Bugg, Wilkes)
M: Ablett, Murphy, Selwood, Masten, Miles, Kerridge (Magner, Gibson)
R: Mumford, Leuenberger (Giles, Redden)
F: Franklin, Fyfe, Pavlich, Martin, Porplyzia, Smith, Saad (Hall, Couch)
$22,700 remaining

Let me know what you think and how i could improve it
ILL RATE YOURS BACK!

tor01doc

You again?!

As balanced as a Chinese gymnast.

As solid as a rock.

As boring as batsh!t!

No it is nice feisty felsty.

Especially your rucks.

Byes covered at this stage with the canny selection of Adcock down back.

Masten is a mid with obvious risk. Could he be a keeper?

In love with your rucks.

Good forwards but can't you decide between Pyfe?

Cheers again.

MartyNadort

Possibly upgrade Pav or Fyfe > Goodes... I have decided to go with Fyfe due to his presence in the Midfield but thats just a personal choice.. Love the rucks... Good team rock solid.

Overall Rating = 8.5-9/10

ben_020285

As always a solid side, felsty!

BACKS: There is no doubt that Deledio is a great SC player but with his limited pre-season and add to that the Tigers tough early draw, I think he is a perfect upgrade target. There's no reason why Scotland can't replicate last season's form and he has looked very good in the pre-season so I would get him in. Adcock is a rick obviously with his injury prone body but could be a risk worth taking. I think Lake is worth the punt.

MIDS: I think there's no doubt that Masten will improve on his average from last year but it means that you now have 1 less rookie in the mids and I think this is the line where the best rookies will come from this year. However, if Masten can average 100 this year then he will be a great pick and will keep the points coming in from your team until you upgrade him. May be worth the risk.

RUCKS: Perfect. Set and forget.

FWDS: Perfect. Wouldnt change a thing.

Great side mate, 9.33/10