Scotland vs. Deledio

[Talisman]

I've had Deledio in all preseason, but I'm a little worried by his injury-interrupted preseason the closer it gets to Rd.1. I also have Goddard and Heath Shaw out of the top 4 prem defs (being God, Scot, DLids, Heater) and 3 other Tigers (Ellis, Morris & Martin in my side). Imagine many other people may be grappling with this so thought I might put it out there for the direct comparison.

[Hot_Dogs]

I am skipping both of them, but if I was to choose I would go with Scotland.

Usually steer clear of the injury interrupted pre-seasons unless price discounted.

[ben_020285]

I initially had Deledio but with his interrupted pre-season there is a good chance that he'll start slowly. Add to that the Tigers tough early draw and it makes the decision to choose Scotland that little bit easier.

Deledio is the perfect backline upgrade target for mine.

[Disco]

I initially had Deledio but with his interrupted pre-season there is a good chance that he'll start slowly. Add to that the Tigers tough early draw and it makes the decision to choose Scotland that little bit easier.

Deledio is the perfect backline upgrade target for mine.

+1

[Torress]

i'm still going to select lids, but decision pending based on this weeks NAB performance. but its handy that scotland is there to switch with if enough doubt.

i don't think Lids really falls into the ''interupted preseaon'' category like most others who have had injury affected preseasons. lids has done the preseason, picked up a minor hammy tear during NAB. i assume he hasn't lost fitness and you often see in the real season players playing a week after these types of niggles.

hopefully he plays a full game, fair chance he will IMO.

[meow meow]

Scotland is old. Just like last year, only worse!
Deledio is injury prone now that he has had one minor injury in his 150 game career!

[Usman]

Scotland is old. Just like last year, only worse!
Deledio is injury prone now that he has had one minor injury in his 150 game career!

fianlly some sense on this topic +1 to meow

[felsty]

What are the breakevens for Scotland and Deledio?

[TheMailman]

What are the breakevens for Scotland and Deledio?

You don't have breakevens at round 1.

They're calculated after round 2

[MontyJnr]

i'm still going to select lids, but decision pending based on this weeks NAB performance. but its handy that scotland is there to switch with if enough doubt.

i don't think Lids really falls into the ''interupted preseaon'' category like most others who have had injury affected preseasons. lids has done the preseason, picked up a minor hammy tear during NAB. i assume he hasn't lost fitness and you often see in the real season players playing a week after these types of niggles.

hopefully he plays a full game, fair chance he will IMO.

+1
not technically an interrupted preseason. looking forward to a 160 from him against GWS this weekend ;D