SIDE TO BEAT....MAYBE!

Started by CFA, March 12, 2012, 12:00:30 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

CFA

I think this is a fair side to beat.....ur thoughts please!

BACKS: Scottland, Birchall, Broughton, Lake, Tomlison, Clarke, Ellis BENCH: Spurr Bugg
MIDS: Pendles, Boyd, Ablett, Mitchell, Murphy, McDonald BENCH: Magner, Pfeiffer
RUCKS: Cox, Giles BENCH: Redden, Stephenson
FORWARDS: Franklin, Fyfe, Martin, Gray, Porps, Smith, Smedts BENCH: Weedon, Kerridge

Remaining Cash - $127,100

If i was to change things please help..... THANKS!

Colliwobblers

good, not a fan of 5 starting elite mids, thats where the best rooks are, other than that looks all very good.

CFA

Quote from: Colliwobblers on March 12, 2012, 01:04:22 AM
good, not a fan of 5 starting elite mids, thats where the best rooks are, other than that looks all very good.

Which mid should I take out n for who??? N where should I spend the cash then??

CFA

Pendles out for masten
Spurr out for Goddard
...... Thoughts now

Remaining cash $59,100

The F.A.R.K.

Quote from: Colliwobblers on March 12, 2012, 01:04:22 AM
good, not a fan of 5 starting elite mids, thats where the best rooks are, other than that looks all very good.

please name these rooks colli??? i am struggling to find 2 decent mids with js and scoring potential. Magner and neale now injured

Insider out

I reckon Skinner will score better and have more JS than weedon

TheMailman

Quote from: The F.A.R.K. on March 12, 2012, 11:49:58 AM
Quote from: Colliwobblers on March 12, 2012, 01:04:22 AM
good, not a fan of 5 starting elite mids, thats where the best rooks are, other than that looks all very good.

please name these rooks colli??? i am struggling to find 2 decent mids with js and scoring potential. Magner and neale now injured

Well

You have

Magner
Neale
Shiel
Coniglio
Tyson
Pfieffer
Zorko
Brown
McDonald
Sexton
Kavangh
Mitchell
Hogan
Stevens
Miles

Just to name about half  :P

JKraz

Im doing 5 premium mids....just becasue the backline premos are looking shakey (goddard lids suckling) and im expecting the forward premos johnson and Goodes to have slow starts to the year....and chapman is a worry becasue of his age imo....I will have to see how he goes....

so in summary I also have 5 mids as they will save trades....as barring injury these guns will not be traded....where if you get rid of say murphey for goodes....he may stink it up for a while anyway

Also for rucks Luey has looked average and im yet to see how the introduction of Hmac will affect goldy....so that too is rsiky, as Lobbe is out for ten weeks redden will get the number one ruck spot and by the time lobbe returns he may retain the number one spot or go up in value enough to cash in $$$

Master Q

Not the side to beat. Very unbalanced. 6.5/10.


CFA


PowerBug

Quote from: JKraz on March 13, 2012, 06:09:55 PM
Im doing 5 premium mids....just becasue the backline premos are looking shakey (goddard lids suckling) and im expecting the forward premos johnson and Goodes to have slow starts to the year....and chapman is a worry becasue of his age imo....I will have to see how he goes....

so in summary I also have 5 mids as they will save trades....as barring injury these guns will not be traded....where if you get rid of say murphey for goodes....he may stink it up for a while anyway

Also for rucks Luey has looked average and im yet to see how the introduction of Hmac will affect goldy....so that too is rsiky, as Lobbe is out for ten weeks redden will get the number one ruck spot and by the time lobbe returns he may retain the number one spot or go up in value enough to cash in $$$
Not sure how it will save you trades, as you'll still need to upgrade in the other positions.

And i don't think the back premiums have done anything bad for you not to pick them.

Pick Jacobs from teh crows, he's done nothing wrong and has the same bye as HMac, Goldy, and Leuenberger.