Chapman & Pavlich vs Mumford & Broughton

Started by Usman, March 06, 2012, 06:38:16 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Chapman & Pavlich vs Mumford & Broughton. Who will score more for overall?

Chapman & Pavlich
4 (25%)
Mumford & Broughton
10 (62.5%)
Other (specify)
2 (12.5%)

Total Members Voted: 2

Usman

Mumford and Broughton fit my structure better but im worried they will not score as much, please choose.

quinny88

I know this is nothing but a guess but..
i would expect 110 from mummy and 95 from broughton= 205
And 105 from chappy and 105 from pav= 200.
Its not really enough to worry about.  I would go mummy and broughton as good ruckman are worth their weight in gold.
Chappy is winding down also, plus could possibly find himself injured on and off

quinny88

sorry chappy+ pav= 210.. im not much for math lol

JamesHarden13

Ever thought of luenberger and deledio as a matchup? Hard to say what to do without seeing rest of your team.

Usman

ye sorry about that, should have posted my team, lids is already in.

Backs: Goddard, Deledio, Broughton or Shaw (still deciding), Duffield, Lake, Ellis, Morris, Smedts, Darley.
Mids: Ablett, Murphy, Hodge, Coniglio, Hogan, Magner, Miles, Clifton.
Rucks: Mumford, Naitanui, Giles, Stephenson.
Forwards: Franklin, Rioli, Martin, N.Riewoldt, Dangerfield, Porplyzia, Smith, 2 rookies.

Take out one forward rookie and porps for the chappy pav combo and put in jenkins or redden in for mummy and hargrave in for broughton so i guess the question is chappy, pav, hargrave and jenkins/ redden vs Mummy, Broughton, porps and an undecided forward rookie, say kerridge?

C.Judd3Votes

Mum/Broughts look the best option. Both can pump out huge scores.