Done.. what do you reckon?

Started by troy goldy, March 06, 2012, 02:08:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

troy goldy

Backs: H Scotland, B Goddard, H Shaw, M Suckling, J Adcock, B Ellis, L Spurr (S Darley, S Morris)

Mids: S Pendlebury, M Boyd, G Ablett Jnr, M Murphy, D Shiel, K Stevens (J McDonald, J Magner)

Rucks: D Cox, J Giles (O Stephenson, S Rowe)

Fwds: P Chapman, L Franklin, M Pavlich, S Sidebottom, S Byrnes, D Smith, A Saad (D Zorko, C Hampton)

15K leftover

Rookies are still up in the air.. mostly Stevens, Saad and Zorko..

Thoughts guys?

yorgis

good side but only if the 1 premo ruck set up works. you do have 3 defenders missing  rnd 13 and 4 forw. in rnd 12

Mr.Craig

No thoughts really, other than good side. Keep a watch on Spurr and Stevens.

crowborr

It's not too bad. I have issues with Adcock as I think at this stage only because hargrave is a better option right now and will free up some cash.

In the rucks I'm unsure why a lot of peole are looking at 1 prem/3 rookies. Giles so far has shown he can play, but the big O has been underwhelming thus far and who knows if Rowe will get much game time with Hampson showing he can take a grab up forward. So who knows if they will even play half a season.

Chappy is a gun, will he be able to keep it up? I'm unsure, he was relatively injury prone a few years ago I feel that although he may not score as well as chappy that a Fyfe/Martin could be the better option this year freeing you up a bit more cash. Could lead to an upgrade of byrnes and or pav.

troy goldy

cheers guys... not worried about byes at this stage.. Hargrave may be an option though he's only had one good NAB cup game so i'll sit on that for a little while... Chappy and Pav both ripped up preseason at their clubs and pav is said to be playing up forward this year which is why i've gone with them.

troy goldy

New team:

Backs: Goddard, Enright, Shaw, Birchall, Hargrave, Ellis, Spurr (Darley, Morris)

Mids: Pendlebury, Boyd, Ablett, Murphy, Shiel, Stevens (McDonald, Magner)

Rucks: Cox, Giles (Stephenson, Rowe)

Fwds: Chapman, Franklin, Pavlich, Martin, Sidebottom, Smith, Saad (Hampton, Horlin-Smith)

$100 leftover

Changes are:
Scotland - Enright
Suckling - Birchall
Adcock - Hargrave
Byrnes - Martin
Zorko - Horlin-Smith

Good or bad changes?