Shane Tuck Vs Barlow

[rioligunn]

Really tough decision, thoughts?  ???

[C.Judd3Votes]

If Barlow is fit, I would choose him, if not then Tuck.

[Usman]

tucks problem has never been finding the footy or scoring, rather following a game plan and getting a game. tread carefully, considering he is only available as a mid, what is the point? not going to be a super prem so he shouldnt fit into your plans. as he is not cheap enough to start and make cash and waste the trade. especially when you cant be sure on getting a game even with the youth policy out the window.

[Colty]

If you want to talk that sort of cash then go for Keiren Jack, he is a better option than both, coming of a great pre season after an injury ravaged 2011.

[Victorius Secret]

neither, its a close call because tuck is $75K cheaper but if i had to choose i would take a fit barlow. theres more upside about him and stats that suggest he should smash it this season (although, i dont read into predicted projections too much...) as for tuck, will players like deledio and conca moving through the mids + the rise of cotchin and martin affect his score?

im sticking with the super in-form proven premos and rookies only in the mids.

[C.Judd3Votes]

Yeah try Lenny?