Rate my team guys?

Started by Marcon, February 23, 2012, 10:53:38 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Marcon

Just looking for some feedback guys, waiting to see the rookies over NAB cup, unsure about premium mids, and gonna take a risk with Zach Smith but pretty happy with other lines.

DEF: Goddard, Delidio, Shaw, Grimes, Lake, Ellis, Bugg (Smedts, Morris)

MIDS: Ablett, A.Swallow, J.Selwood, Hayes, Sheil, T.Mitchell (Zorko, McDonald

RUCKS: Mumford, Z.Smith (Giles, Stephensen)

FWDS: Franklin, Pav, O'Keefe, Martin, J.Brown, Pfieffer, Trealoar (Walsh, Crozier)

Ringo

Def: Sound - Just the concern with Grimes but imo minor if he has a good NAB cup.
Mids: Sound (Gotta say that as identical to mine at the moment)
Rucks: Sound - Smith I think may surprise this year - Bulked up and remember he is a late convert to AFL as well having been a soccer player,
Forwards - Would prefer Goodes to ROK but money is probably the issue here.

Very Sound team - Good luck 8.5/10

Marcon

Thanks for the feedback mate, really didnt know who to pick between Goodes and O'Keefe but ill have a look over the coming weeks before my final decision.

Didnt expect many people to have Andrew Swallow, but im hoping for another big year from him :)

Ringo

#3
Forgot to add Smith is also my second ruck.
With being made Captain I expect Swallow to at least maintain last years scores and perhaps increase.

With Goodes I know he has a better second half traditionally but with the Swans draw in the first 10 weeks only playing 2 of last years top 8 think he may break that tradition this year.