Shiel or Clifton??

[Jimbo_11]

so the rumor the shiel was in a moonboot is not true, he just had his appendix out and reports are that he should be right for round 1

just wondering who would be a better pick up, out of him and clifton,
i know clifton is mature age, but shiel is a ball magnet and both should get plenty of game time so JS isnt an issue

[Justin Bieber]

Yeah jump on him. He will be already one of the most popular players in the game.

[BGK]

so the rumor the shiel was in a moonboot is not true, he just had his appendix out and reports are that he should be right for round 1

just wondering who would be a better pick up, out of him and clifton,
i know clifton is mature age, but shiel is a ball magnet and both should get plenty of game time so JS isnt an issue

Where did you get the info that he wasn't in a moon boot?

[BGK]

so the rumor the shiel was in a moonboot is not true, he just had his appendix out and reports are that he should be right for round 1

just wondering who would be a better pick up, out of him and clifton,
i know clifton is mature age, but shiel is a ball magnet and both should get plenty of game time so JS isnt an issue

Where did you get the info that he wasn't in a moon boot?

I just read Colliwoblers post in the other thread.

[mezzoculo]

Sam Reid (GWS, $125k) is another option. Traded from the dogs and (from what I hear) played well last weekend.

[Mr.Craig]

Shiel has been in my team for ages but I think that people might forget about him a bit if he doesn't play any NAB. Both guys should be excellent picks.

[elephants]

Shiel for me. Clifton needs to show a bit more for me... Reid did look good.

[Jukes]

I have both. Would give up Clifton before Shiel though. Both will average great hopefully 80.

[dyslexiauntied]

I have both as well.