Clifton vs. Caddy?

[Talisman]

Looking at my mid-5 spot, interested in people's thoughts on GWS' Clifton vs. GC's Caddy? Any thoughts?

[Colliwobblers]

anyone between $120k and $350K is a massive risk, needs to become a keeper or make a lot of cash or a basic rookie would have been a better pick and saved you money initially to spend elsewhere.

I have caddy i think he will have an awesome season but it is a big risk as for clifton much safer bet and ill have him too with shiels

[Talisman]

Yep, good call - thinking along similar lines - just trying to decide is Caddy is justifiable for the extra $$$ as you say.

Interested that you have both Caddy & Clifton + Shiel - does that mean you don't have JMac - is Caddy a better option than he is in your opinion?

(& you mean Dylan Shiel not Liam Shiels, right?)

[Colliwobblers]

yeah d shiel, i don't have mcdonald, im tempted but im worried if he gets the 7 or so straight full games we need to trade him in, being a senior player / coach his game time worries me, not his scoring potential just his game time.