Please Rate My Supercoach Team V2

[DanTh3Man]

Backs: Deledio, Heppell, H Shaw , H Scotland, Buntine, B Ellis, Smedts

EMRG: Mohr, T Bugg

Midfielders: Ablett, M Boyd, Goddard, J Redden, Haynes, J Mcdonald

EMRG: A Miles, S Gibson

Rucks: D Cox, Giles

EMRG: J Witts, J Staley

Forwards: Franklin, Fyfe, D Petrie, Pavlich, Okeefe, Treloar, Cooyou

EMRG: Skinner, A Pattison

Please rate and give me feedback. thanks  :D

changed it up a bit. give me some suggestions on some good rookies??

[Mushi]

Not too bad.

Backs: Johnson is a bit of a unique pick, 50/50 really, hopefully he learnt from last season with what he has done, dont be surprised if he goes out again though. Other possible options, Grimes, Duigan, Waters (if you like an extra risk).
Dont bother with Stratton i reckon, get another rookie for about 113k - 150k and then use the money to upgrade Hibberd, i just really dont like Hibberd with his security, performance ect ect. Possible options, Bower (???), Docherty, Tomlinson, Morris and Broughton, Suckling, Adcock and even Shaw if you can squeezer the cash.

Midfielders: Way too much money invested here, you're looking at playing usually about 2 rookies. I do actually like Goddard in the midfield instead of the backline ONLY if you can bulk up the backs a bit. See really any of the rookies and make a decision, there are plenty of them!

Rucks: ALWAYS play 2 fully priced ruckman, just too much reliance on just a kid.

Forwards: Rooey, Hale, Vickery and Varcoe are all jokes IMO. Rooey, dont see him doing too much in the future. Hale, at best a second ruck and which is injured (not 100% sure). Vickery, just another average players, dont see him being Mumford like or really anyone. Varcoe, he has his moments but nothing consistent to being a supercoach star. If you do change things around and get some extra cash downgrade Varcoe and upgrade someone like Hale and/or Vickery.

7/10

[DanTh3Man]

Thanks for the feedback. its really helpful.
i do agree with most of what you have said but i have a feeling that hale and varcoe will play well.
with reiwoldt i have to agree though i never was really sure about him.

with the midfielders im looking to have a powerhouse midfield i believe that has the most pints in it. though if a find a good enough rookie then i might make some changes

thanks again for the advice!

[felsty]

great team.. cant understand why you dont have big o in the rucks but.. best option out there!
picked some high rookies, buntine etc. - take a few of them away and downgrade. lot of rookies will score the same anyway

love the forward line, will be awesome, good mids and strong backline, i dont like scotland personally, 8.5/10

[DanTh3Man]

thanks, i just need to have a look at some rooks that are solid and cheap. then ill swap some of the expensive ones over. :)